The Archive · 1925

Your WUCHANG CoRRESPONDENT

Wuchang, Dee. 20, 1924 — WU PEI-FU AND PUBLIC OPINION

To the Editor of the "NorrH-Cxiva Darr News."

Sm—I hed the pleasure of reading an article on "Wu Pei-fu and Hupeh" by your Wuchang correspondent and your own remarks on it as published in yesterday's issue of your valuable paper. While I feel for your Wuchang correspondent every goodwill and affection for the views he so admirably expressed, I must beg leave to differ with him in point of reason and fact, It seems your correspondent is far too harsh to Wu Pei-fu and gives far too much credit to the supposed public opinion in Hupeh, That Wu is wrong-minded and undesirable at, present I agree; but that he is selfish and treacherous T deny. Of all warlords in China Wu fat one time was the most powerful and he is at present the poorest. What Marshal and Tuchun does not retire with comfortable millions to enjoy, the spoils of plunder and dishonesty? But Wu, according to newspapers, is depending for port on the gifts of his form inferiors and is living on very secondary rice and one vegetable dish. That be had been the outstanding source of war and trouble might be true; but at least he made wars not for his own profit, but for that of his old master, Tsao Kun or evan in part xt least, for the ultimate union and peace of his country. He tried to unite China bby force and he failed. Is this very much to blame?—Wu falls and what follows? A state of utter anarchy, wretched confusion; of worse trouble than ever. We see warlords who are as insatiable of power as Wu, but who are more selfish and Jess honest. Wu has [How -acknowledyred hi -defemty-he says he will not fight ary more; and we have no reason to doubt his words. The greatest menace to Hupeh at present is not Wu Pei-fa, but Hu Ching-yi whose ambition seems to be already carving the province out for himself. Tt is on the intter, that the so-called public opinion in Hupeh should bring force to bes and not on Wu Pei-fu, the fall very pessimistic about the future of China; and because of my fear for the selfish military leaders, but for the inadequacy and helplessness of the so-called public opinion. Democracy demands government by public opinion, not by force; and force is a menace only so long as true public opinion does not exist or else is too weak to express itself. And this is exactly the true condition in China at present. The supposed public opinion we see today is very little of "the insurgence of a new democratic force;" instead of "stronger than the power of the tuchuns," it is powerless before them. That public opinion in. Hupeh succeeds in keeping Wu out is due rather to ix own failing strength and to his real sympathy for the suffering of the people, and not to any supposed strength on the part of the public opinion iteclf, n Hupeh, instead ut ought really to be grateful to him for the present safety of their life and property; for we must not mistake for a' moment that Wu, the fearless, can be afraid of their' opinion, If he docs not enter Hupeh, it is because he him: self seos no reason for entering it, refer anyone who doubts words to the last war between Kiangsu and Chekiang. At that ime the so-called public opinion here appeared as strong as that in Hupeh to-day. "He who opens hostility first should be cursed by us," said the people at first; when conditions became more critical, the Prominent gentry and merchants went so far as to kneel before the tuchuns, asking for merey: The only power wielded by publi opinion ix to kneel and to ask for merey; at the final moment it ca do nothing but that! If peace ie successfully maintained, well Ww might aay the public opinion iw strong, for it has prevented wer! intention to fight, they tread alt [public opinion under foot and then the latter must satisfy itself with hoping; the war will come quickly to an end. The Hupeh merchants threatened to shoot Wu Pei-fu, should he appear in Hankow; but T should like to see what they will do if Ha Ching-yi determines to go down. I must say public opinion is cowardly, for it flatters the powerful and strikes only at a fallen man.

Public opinion, as we see to-day, self-conceited, self-c 4 narrow, selfish, and as frail as harlot.' Were -not the Anfu party caiters a few years ago? But now homage is once more paid to them, San Yen-si (Sun Yat-sen) burned houses and killed men in Canton but yesterday; but to-day innumer-fable cables are addressed to him, raising him to the sky. If Tsao Kun usurped presidency by bribery, was that in any way exceptional? Too often his loudest accusers are [themselves guilty of the same dishonesty. Marshal Chi leaves Na king; and Marshal Lu with hi Fengtien supporters is coming? does that in any way better the future prospects? What Hupeh people care is to see no war being fought in Hopeh; Kiangsu people Uk merely to prevent: The people in recent vay here published a cable of theirs to the belligerents saying, "Might it please your goodness to change your line of brttle a bit, so. that our city will not be involved!" I condemn this sort of public opinion selfish and heartless, 1 consider as the greatest mie pediment to China's progress not the lawlessness of the militarists, the corruption of the officials, but the inadequacy of public opinion to make any strong stand whatever on principle and reason, At present the only ery we hear is, "Keep ante our life and property: it should be, "let us stand on justice and righteousness."

Where justice and vighteousnees are We must sacrifice Pence in war not always an evil. Let us go into ourselves, fighting for the principles for which we stand; and not be_mere passive onlookers to the ming all China, 'The newspapers are to blame for their apathy to the development of true public opinion, 'Too. often they are instruments' to politicians: most of them seek to record only the opinions of men who are alrendy famous oF in high position; while poor, plain commoner who has neither' money nor influence is liable to see hie views rejected and hie articles unpublished?

Tam, ete, Shunyhai, Dee. 80, 1984, *We think it permissible to say /—there can be no question of thus giving away hie identity—that. the writer of this striking letter

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account