The Archive · 1927

One Cause Ruled Out

Ho pointed out that by his Honours Mr, Jones then addressed the Jury.

ruling the action for false imprison. ment had gone, and there remained only the action for malicious prosecution. He would endeavour to) show that, throughout, Mr, Davey thad been" influenced by no other motive than that of serving the terests of justice, and when he!

[brought the action against Ws he did so in the confident belief that the was justified on all the facts in his possession. Mr. Dovey would tell them in his evidence that Wallis was engaged by the "Shanghsi Mercury" to solicit advertising, and the had no authority whatsoever to collect accounts. At no time had he been instructed by Mr. Davey, or by anyone in authority on ths "Shanghai Mercury" staff, to collect the account of Garner, Quelch Ca, Ld. He did this on his own responsibility entirely.

'As far as the "Shanghai Mercury' }was concerned, all they knew about this account was that on August 3, 1925, Mr. Wallis collected from! Garner, Quelch the sum of $40 in leash, and $151 on a post-dated compradore order. This money was paid over to the compradore of the "Shanghai Mercury," leaving a balance, so far as Mr. Davey wes aware, of $103. Neither Mr. Davey nor anyone else on the stof Knew that any more than this $191 had been paid. Neither Mr. Wallis nor Mr, Haynes ever mentioned the $103, or a receipt for that amount to Mr. Davey, and as far as he knew it was outstanding, The Discovery This happened in August, 1925, and the following month Mes: Gomer, Quelch went into liquidation. The usual advertisements were inserted in the local newspapers, avd Mr. Davey, on the same day,' sent:

an account for the balance of! [the money, including the $108, which he still believed to be owing to his firm. This in itself was corroboration that Mr, Davey had no know Tedge of the receipt for $103. It was not until a considerable time ater that Messrs. Seth, Mancell 'MeLure, who were in charge of the liquidation of Garner, Quelch & Cos books, came to the question of the \"Shanghai Mercury's" accounts, and when they did so they saw' immediately that something was /wrong, and they got into touch with. Mr. Davey. On September 23 Mr. [Quelch, at the instigation of Mr. MeLure, saw Mr, Davey and pro-Jduced' the receipt given to him by Wallis for the whole amount of their account to the "Shanghai Mercury."

The jury would remember that in his evidence Mr. Quelch distinctly said that at no time did he mention to Mr. Davey anything about the receipt for $108 made out to Haynes, with the result that Mr. Davey wes il_under the impression that this amount had not been handed in. By new Mr. Davy was considerably worried, and he went straight back to his office and made very full investigation of this books, only to find that ro mention was made there or anywhere else concerning this sum of $103, On Friday, September 24, Mr, Davey took advice of some friends on the matic and went round to see Mr. King, the Magistrate, und between them a complaint was drawn up, after Mr. King advised Mr. Davey to sco Mr, E. T, Maitland, the police prosecutor, and get him to take the case up. The warrant wns issued on the Saturday.

Mr. Jones here pointed out to the Jjury that the warrant was issued by Mr. King within his own discretion as q judicial officer, and Mr. King considered that Mr. Davey had a prima facie case. The fact that the warrant wat issued on a saturday was not the deliberate} tent of Mr. Davey, but followed fu natural sequence to a natural chain of events, as he had described.

'The case was taken up by Br. 'Maittand, the public prosecutor, and Mr. Wallis was charged by' the police, and not by Mr, Davey acting a private individual in rroseeution. Then again, meri to the second charge under the Valsification of Accounts Act, this was brought by Mr. Maitland again, he would remind them, the public prosecutor—without Mr Davey's being consulted at all That second charge had nothing to do with Mr. Davey or the "Shangh: was not until the proceedings the police court that Mr. Davey. ever heard anything about the: receipt given to Wallis by Mr. Quelch for $103, to be credited to Mr, Haynes's wine bill. The fence would submit that Mr. Wallis's evidence on this point was not true. With regard to the issuance of a warrant for Wellis's arrest, instend a summons ordering "him to attend the court when called upon, thin was issued by Mr, Davey because it was commonly rumoured that Wallis intended following

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account