The Archive · 1927

A Question of Law

They then came to the question of probable reason or caus was a question of law, and, therefore, one for the Judge to decide Jand not the jury. Before deciding it, however, there was a questi lof fact which the jury would hav to consider, end that was: did the "Shanghai Mercury" have true Knowledge of all the facts concerning the transaction between Mr. Wallis and Garner, Quelch & Ca. lvefore starting the prosecution? Or did they have a full opportunity for direovering the true facts before setting the law in motion? The jury's "decision on this point very materially afooted the Judge's con-

They then came to the question of malice, Malice in a prosecution, of this kind meant the presence of} some improper and wrongful motive, The lack of reasonable or probable:

for starting the prosecution was to a certain extent evidence of malice in itself. It might be the want of proper care in bringing the charge was so glaring that it could only be ascribed to an ulterior motive, The Judge went on to point out that it-was 2 very serious thing to start a prosecution such "Bs this. The transaction in question had taken place a year ago, money had been received from Mr, Wallis in connexion wi tered into their books wi ment. The compradore of the firm, to whom Mr. Wallis had said he had told all the facts of the transaction was in their employ when the: proceedings were started, and could have explained what, if anything, had happened. These were points which the jury had to consider when they came to decide whether not the prosecution was started purely and simply in the interests of justice, In considering damages, providel of course that they had to consider them, the jury had the right to include direct expenses incurred, such as legal fees, ete, and also the damage to a man's character, the indignity which he had suffered fin his feelings in being lodged gaol, and having to face a criminal) charge in a public court. In short, they had to judge for themsel what amount would compensate him for the evil which had been done, His Honour, to make things simpler for them, wrote out the {following questions for the jury to (a) Was the "Shanghat Mercury" fully aware of all the facts concern ting the transaction be: ween Wallis, and Garner, Quelch & Ca. before they started the prosecution?

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account