The Archive · 1931

AN OPEN SPACE?

Mar. 2.

The sudden enthusiasm shown for the proposed purchase of the Majestic Hotel site for purposes variously described should be sufficient to put the Council and the ratepayers on guard lest something be done which may bea future source of regret. So far as can be humanly fore: seen it is unlikely that such a transaction will involve the community in any loss. Possibly if the site had eventually to be sold it would realize a profit, but that appears to involve the re-adoption of the principle of municipal trading which could searcely be justified so quickly after the sale of the Electricity Department, One of the difficult in considering the proposal as it now stands ix the lack of a cut-and-dried statement of the exact purposes to which the Property would be put if acquired. The suggestions appear to include any or all of the following—(1) to maintain it as an open space: (2) to maintain it gan open space and a civic centre including town hall, library and possibly a museum: (3) to transfer the whole of the municipal offices to new buildin to be erected thereon, the balance of the land to be used open space, and to sell the existing munici subject of main as an open space under any tone of the three suggestions outlined above in vol sideration of the question as to whether such an expenditure would be justified in view of the area it would serve. Based on the census of 1930, a plan was Published in last week's Municipal Gazette showing the density of population in figures per acre. That plan shows that in the Western district beyond Carter Road the population per acre varies between 48 and 186; between Carter Road and the Bund it ranges from 50 to 414, while in the Northern and East ern Districts the minimum: per acre is 52 at The Point, and 494 in the Harbin Road District. On the basis of population, therefore, it would seem that the Northern and Eastern Districts have the most urgent claims for open spaces. and if a figure apparently between Tls. 3,500,000 and Tls. 4,000,000 isto. be spent inthe Western District, how much should the com: munity be called to spend in areas where the need is obviously more pressing?

The second. proposition attractive from an wsthetic point of view. It has to be conceded that Shanghai being of the size and importance is, stands under a reproach in not having something of the nature of a civie centre along the lines suggested. But is it not somewhat late in the day to attempt. to remedy matters?" This is the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account