The Archive · 1927

Some False Assumptions

Treaty Revision Students and Nationalism: Are They What They Seem i (Contributed the Chinese Jor many ears on Terme me acho hav lived amo We have the highest authority for the statement that in the Divine presence men are "not heard for their much speaking." But with men it is otherwise; for if 4 statement is repeated frequently enough, ft ce nes to be believed, not because it has stood the test of critical ex: amination, but merely because of its incessant repetition, May it not then be a healthy exercise to chal: Tenge some of the assumptions that fare so easily taken for granted in these days?

The Treaties For example, it appears to be generally assumed that there is in China to-day a great, united, ntuncous movement for the re: vision of the treaties with foreign powers. We do not propose to dis-jous whether or not these treaties ought to be altered. For ourselves we never regarded them as other than temporary expedients and we, in common with our home government, are quite prepared to recognize that they are becoming obsolete. The point is whether the Chinese nation desires that they should be revised. Is that assumption (rue oF false?

Surely anyone with any. rear Knowledge of China proper knows quite well that, so far as the general populace is concerned, it is sheer nonsense, Would it not be much nearer to the truth to say that the students (with very many honourable exceptions) desire to escape examinations; that the farmers desire to cultivate their crops with out the danger of spoliation at the hands of armed coolies; that the merchant's main concern is to make money without corrupt, official exactions; that the artisans are hoping. for a living wage and congenial conditions; while most of the soldiers tare out for loot. These are genuine desires and wherever you go it me Iand China you find "abundant evi. dence of them. We recognize, of course, that a vast array of facto boycotts, riots, insults to cte—appear to con= tradict us, But what do these things prove? "Merely this: that large numbers of people have been hood-dor frightened into unnatural actions, And deeds that are per formed as a result of external agitation are no proof of a spontaneons movement.

Chinese But not Leaders Now we are quite prepared 9 lexpeet that our position will be ce tested on the ground that many well-known Chinese leaders have declared that this movement against the treaties really exists; but that merely Jeads us to question a second assumption: that—foreign-trained. Chinese students represent China. Do they even know China? How many of them have lived a normal Chinese life? How many of them would dream of undertaking a rear Chinese task in actual Chinese surroundings? While we are ready to make tre dual admission that they are Chinese and that some of them are leaders, we are still compelled to deny the seemingly inevitable inference, that they are therefore Chi nese leaders; for they are the pro-duet of something that is not purely Chinese, They have had advantages They have had they have seen institutions and imbibed foreign ideas; but in the nature of the case this new culture has been an outward thing, something acquired not something grown. And mors disappointing than all, they have returned to their own land wiiers there is no use, for it. They are fish out of water. "They found the for-ign surroundings congenial, but they cot id not stay in them, Neithee can they create similar surroundings in their own country. They have a grudge against the universe and they must vent it upon someone. They are not to be blamed, for they "were not personally. responsible

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account