The Archive · 1921

How Cxixese Harp Lap

Now let me take the admitted history of this land. Some ago Koh Yue-chow and his nephew bought it jointly. It was registered in the names of Messrs. Davies Brooke in Consulate books: and declarations of trust were handed to the purchasers messrs. Davies Brooke. This is a well-known practice here in Shanghai: and under it much land, really owned by Chinese, appears in Consulate records as foreign-owned. This practice, criticized by Mr. Wilkinson, has at least the tacit approval of the Consulates concerned: though I believe I am right in saying that the declarations of trust are not registered or recognized " in the foreign land offices concerned, It is entirely out of my province to criticize the system.

In June or July 1920 Koh and his nephew requested Messrs. Davies Brooke to make the necessary arrangements with the Consulates concerned to cancel the various existing title deeds for half the land in the name of Koh and one for the other half in the name of the nephow. This was put in hand, and the old title deeds were sent into the British Consulate. On September 27, 1920, Koh formally requested Messrs. Davies & Brooke to transfer his share to the present plaintiffs: this being in accordance with one of the conditions of the declaration of trust; and Messrs. Davies Brooke without calling in those, declarations issued the two documents on that date to the two plaintiffs. These run as follows "By authority given us by Mr. Kon Yue-chow, this 27th September 1920 we hereby declare that two-fifths' of the area Lot 4,405 are transferred to Mr. Chen Sih-chee and three-fifths to Mr. Koh Ching-ming (plaintiffs in this case) and we issue this receipt in duplicate, one to each, also a duplicate declaration of trust to each as soon as the title deed is returned by the British Con-

(Sgd.) Davies & Brooke.'*

Early in October, Hayes' action in the Mixed Court against Koh was begun, and notice of one of the interlocutory orders was sent to Messrs. Davies & Brooke by Hay solicitors. Messrs. Davies & B: notified (October 26) the Plaintiffs of this and asked ror the return of the documents of September 27. The plaintiffs did net comply, but put the matter into their lawyers hands,' and seem to have taken no further steps till after the commencement of the action in this Court against Messrs. Davies & Brooke. So far, I have only aS out known on admitted facts. On November 2 Hayes got a decree from the Mixed Court on hie motion for judgement and for execu tion.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account