The Archive · 1921

Mr. Hayes's Contentions

On the other hand, Hayes ruts forward this point: that under the judgement of the Mixed Court the beneficial interests in the land have been adjudged to belong to Koh and therefore now to himself: that the circumstances surrounding all the transactions between Koh and the plaintiffs are so peculiar that they cannot be trusted and that no such decree ought to be made. First of all repeat what I said about the Mix Court judgement: I cannot regard it as saying more than that execution may or shall issue against the interests of Koh thes judgement debtor in certain named lands: it iz clear that the true ownership of these lands was not and could not be an issue in the suit; and therefore I cannot -put Hayes in_ the position suggested by Mr. McNeill.

It is then urged that the mortgage deed is.not in regular from: it doss not identify the land: it was never communicated to Messrs. Davies Brooke the known registered owners of the land: it leaves uncertain whether the monies sought to be secured had been paid beforehand or were to be paid and is also uacertain as to other matters: that it was very insufficient security for the money alleged to be owing. But it is not really suggested that, genuine, it was not a valid arrangement as between Koh and the plaintiffs here: and really very little has been urged against its genuineness. In fact no - cross-examination was addressed to the writer and witness of the document.

Then I come to the document of that Mr. Davies abesiderea the September 27, and ijyis noteworthy.

plaintiffs were safe when they had that document.

His firm issued it fully believing the instructions of Koh and without~

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account