Nov.
We publish to-day the actual letters recently sent out by the National Christian Council to its constituents in the missionary field of China, on what should be their attitude towards extraterritoriality and the revision of "unequal" treaties. These letters, it will be remembered, and the whole attitude of the N.C.C. were strongly criticized by a missionary correspondent in our last Tuesday's issue. Subsequently Mr., G. W. Sheppard, secretary of the British and Foreign Bible Society and a member of the Committee of the N.C.C., wrote in defence of its action which he declared our contribu-for had traduced; he also vigorously objected to the account which the latter had given of a speech made by Mr. E. C, Lobenstine, secretary of the N.C.C, at' a meeting of the Shanghai Missionary Association. Our contributor replied that he could produce plenty of people who had understood Mr. Lobenstine's remarks as he had done, and as for the N.C. letters he maintained that it was very easy to read the meaning between the lines, Now we do not know what Mr, Lobenstine said of the Missionary Associa. tion; but do know what he put his name to. As for reading between the lines, do not see much necessity for mental ex-excise of that kind. The large woolly head of the "nigger in the woodpile" obtrudes itself in every sentence.
"regularity, preference' for the three pet cents" very likely began life Radical, a free-thinker and a down-with-everything apostle. But in no country have the student body.been permitted such lengths as in China. Our Taiku correspondent, in a letter dated October 29, described how even in Shansi, the model province of China, the Students' Association are the terror of all officials. To-day our Wuchang correspondent reports that the Commissioner of Education has resigned chiefly because he cai not face the students. In El land, university undergraduates peers not excepted, have fr quently known the inside of a police cell. But in China the Central Government writes to the Diplomatic Body that students are above the law, "in no circumstances ought they to be treated as common wrong-doers.' The licence thus given to stud ents—many of whom are little more than schoolboys—the e couragement to those from whom merchants, doctors, lawyers and officials should come one day to consider themselves above all discipline, the harm done by the neglect of their studies, is one of the most serious matters China has to amend. Here and there a man may be found like Governor Chao. Heng+ti of Hunan, clear-sighted to the supreme evil of allowing the students to be corrupted and resolute to fight it. But the great] majority of officials and those who should take the lead are either frightened or supine. It may be mentioned as a word of warning to the students themselves, that if Moscow gets her way in China, they will be the first whom she will turn and rend: Russia' example, that "country the wild disposition" as Governor Chao calls it, shows that no class is more. the object of the Bolshevik's deadly hatred than the intelligentsia. anti-|'Today the Red war is against! Dr.
We do not think that any dispassionate reader will have any difficulty in finding that our missionary contributor was wholly justified in his strictures. Writing on October 23 Mr. Lobenstine (for the N.C.C.,) recalled that some months ago the Kung Li Hui in North China (the Congregational Mission) had voted to request the N.C.C. "to approach the responsible representatives of the foreign governments, asking for the abolit{on of all unequal treaties." The subsequent behaviour of the N.C.C. reminds us faintly of Balaam going from height to height in the hope of finding some spot from which he might curse Israel. Instead of telling the Kung Li Hui as many will think it should have done, that such questions are not the busi> ness of missionaries, it decid-get support from the mission field before taking ction. So it wrote.to the missionary bodies urging them to consider the question "with a to such action as to them ise." And it urged that, jonid be no delay because the conference on extraterritoriality was to begin on December. 18; and "in order that such decisions as are reached shall have the largest influence" those decisions must come to hand before that date or while the cqnference is sitting; and, most amazing advice of all, the mlasionary bodies are requested to, report their decisions, not to the N.C.C., but "to the Legations of their respective nations." Later on there is a statement that the NAE. does not consider discussion of the—"toleration clauses" sufficient: "It believes, that the whole question of extra territoriality should, be carefully. studied": and a whole sheaf of suggestive information.is. enclosed for the guidance of discussions. The letter closes. with, further emphasis on the need, af, early consideration of the al tion. As if this were not 4 Lobenstine wrote again on,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.