The Archive · 1921

Mr. Balfour by the Way

Essays, Specutative asp Pourricat. By the Right Hon. A. J. Balfour.

(Hodder and Stoughton. 12s, 6d.

net.)

Some of the papers and lectures collected in this volume date from so for back as 1894, while others owe their inspiration to particular phases of the Great War. But they are alike in illustrating Mr. Balfour's" wonderful command of the intellectual resources of the English language—his power of combining the triumphs of rbetorical balance and polish with a sensi tive recognition of all the true relevancies of his theme. Resonant effects are apt to owe much to a judicious ignoring of what might break their simplicity. Mr. Balfour is far too keen a sportsman of the mind to accept such short cuts to eloquence. He delights in exploring all the alternatives of thought, in giving every considera-! tion its due weight, and in lending his emphasis the more effect, when it arrives, from a recollection of the reserves so scrupulously minuted. The value of such a trained temper and refined dialectic to the diplomacy of the Allies can be better appreciated to-day when, in re-reading his deliverances on '"'The Freedom of the Seas" and on "The Foundations of a Durable Peace," it is easier to realize the outlook of that neutral audience to which they were directed. His words have not infrequently the ring of the great historians.

But it is in the more expansive treatment given to purely intellect tual discussions, like those of "Decadence" and of ''Beauty: and the Criticism of Beauty" that Mr. Balfour's mental grasp and his opulence of culture are most luxuriantly displayed. The question of whether there are '"'subtle changes in the social tissue of old communities which make them, as time goes on, less resistant to the external attacks and the internal disturbances by which all ecommunities are threatened," rust be nearly as old as political reflexion. But the appeal of the general problem, the standard illustration of the Roman Empire and the crucial application to our own case, are all endowed here with a glowing interest as if each of them had newly burst upon human thought. Those who may recall the lecture as delivered will find in an appended note some reflexions peculiarly apposite to present-day discussions of Progress.

Democracy is an excellent thing, but, though quite consister: t with progress, ib ig nOt progressive per se. Its value is regulative, not dynamic; and if it meant (as it never does) substantial uniformity instead of legal oquility, we should become fosilizel at once. Move. ment may be controlled or checked by the mai it is initiated and made effective by the few.

For light-handed and yet exact consideration of elusive questions, the Romanes Lecture on zsthetics is a highly characteristic masterpiece. The mutual relations of taste. judgement and generalization in matters of art could scarcely be set forth with greater lucidity or have a better seasoning than the lecturer's manifest delight in the delicate equilibrium which the subject imposes on himself. It is a gymnastic" of no ordinary quaity.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account