The Archive · 1931

Trade Mark Ruling

Minister of Industry's Decision in La Perla del Oriente C igor Case An important ruling has been decision _on this appeal was reach-made by Dr. H. H, Kung, Ministry ed, the former Ministry of Industry, of Industry, in connection with the Commerce and Labour was re-La, Perla del Oriente trade marks organized into this Ministry, so in China, In the "North-China Daily this case is now under the considera-"of March 24, the decision ion to be decided by this Ministry. given By, the London Registrar, Reasons rade Marks regarding these trade These two- trade marks, "La Perla del Oriente" and "El Cometa del Oviente," were originally used aces Incorporated by @ Belgian company. At the dis-concern represented by Messrs. solution of this company all the Fleming, Franklin and Allmann and, assets, including these trade marks, Were" transferred to. Ingenohl: dissatistact the second deci Mr. Li Ching) expressed their Ingenohl, after he acquired said sion of the f Trade Marks business and trade mark rights, put fon the trade marks "La Perla del the word Ingenohl above the trade Oriente" and "El Cometa del named in order to signify, his per-Oriente" and appeared to the Min sonal. right and ownership of the fry of Industry. The "Bureau of perty. He. also. allowed" the Trade Marks, of the Ministry of aid trade marks to be used on the Industry, Commerce & Labour, cigars manufactured in factories ted trade marks registration to Situated both in Slanila and. in Ungenohl. (represented, by Messrs.

Hongkong. He "also furthermore registered them with the Chinese understood that Oriente Rodger and H. Huang); 1 Maritime Customs at Shanghai Fabrien de Tobacon intend to lodge 1907, Evideneed by these, it is al-{fates appedt against De. Kam ready quite sufficiently proved that the right of registration -at_ the Chinese. Maritime Customs belongs to Ingenohl personally. Furthermore, appeal tolews—Der Kung fil denon on_ the One. appellant being dissatisfied the factory" at. Manila was the personal property of Ingenohl, and Bureau of Trade Barks, ith the second decision of the) was nota company organization Erade marie La Perla del Oren nor any form of legal "person trid. "El Gometa del Oriente," a a8. to own any property rights, Fehearing and appeal was, made to There is, therefore, no doubt that this, Ministry. Decision is hereby this trade mark right does not be-Tong to that factory, but belo exclusively to Ingenohl personally, Judgment Since it ig the personal property Rehearing appeal is dismissed. of Ingenohl, it should. not," there-'The decision of the Bureau of fore, be alfécted at all by. the con-'Trade Marks on the trade marks fiseation and sale of the factory in "La Perla del Oriente" and Bi Manila because the action of the Cometa del Oriente" made at the U."S. Government "can only, fective as far as within the limit appeal (setond decision) is to of the jurisdiction of U. 8, terri-upheld, Facts ory; and the object of sale is only limited to the property in the These two trade marks Philippine Islands. Ingenoht's pro-originally used by a Belgian tobacco company. When this 8 erty factory. and trade mark Fights in the Philippine Islands can Oissglved, all its busin be confiscated, but his properties, good will including the trade mutt Tights of all Kinds outside of the find trade marks rights were tran: Philippine Islands. cannot be affectferred. to the person of Ingenobl ed in' any. sense, This can be Since then these two trade mar) evidenced by the fact that the facto. Ingenohl tory in Hongkong is still his) pro. Perey, tod nek im any Sense attested such action, Perutactared at Mania and, Hongevento use them sons, there is not the slightest Based, upon' the, foregoing rea. Kam, and. in HO? registered them Goubt that the ight of reaiatration with the Chinese Maritime Customs with the Chinese Maritime Castome Numbers 8416 ud. 841 ig the Shanghai with the _respective Tattrally dongs to. Ingenohlperfonally." The appellant has, never Buropean War, the U.S. Governfreeeeded to thig right. And "fare ent mistook Ingenohl as an enemy' thermore, "appellant used' these ftuctioned his. Manila factory, with fade eke much Tater than the were first used by "Tngenahl, Ace Tording to the provision of Article After Olsen & Ca, bought the fac-get the ade Mann Yaw, he marks with the, Chinese Maritime Appellant cannot dispute Ingenoh's ABR ES okese reade marks, Fina Inve that there isin error. inthe decision of the Burear of Trad

fey. on this appeal. is therefore Sara the dion War, Ingenohl protested to the rendered as appeared under judg-Government, claiming that he a Belgian and that the U. S. ment.

wu

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account