The Archive · 1926

THE WELSH REVIVAL—A CORRECTION

fo the Editor of the NortH-Cutwa Datty News"

Sm,—I would not have the temority to challenge any statement in' jan editorial of yours but from the: conviction that, such was mistaken On December 23 the concluding Paragraph of your leading article spoke of "the extraordinary, almost fanatical fervour among" Gen. Feng's troops, and you illustrate ment" with the remark: "There may come a violent reaction towards the old Adam, such as, was seen in Wales a fow years ago after the! hysterical revivalist,, wave stirred up. by the preaching of young! Evan Thomas!"

The Welsh "revivalist" you reter to was Evan Roberts, That error of itself made me immediately doubt if, your remark sprang from fany first-hand evidence. Personal fcontaet with either the man of the movement which was stirring Wales just 20 years ago would make it almost impossible ever to forget the name of the central figure!

T was then on the staff of a paper which gave special prominence throughout to that revival. Its editor and his wife went down to Wales soon after it began and stayed days'if not weeks watching its development. Several of my jour-alist colleagues visited revival centres when the movement with its Bacher ney were men othe. to|doeth lant excitement was at its

form a sane, well inion, men accustomed to re ferent to anything they had hitherto seen and reported, but they never suggested "hysterical" Jo a descriptive adjective. One of them wrote a book about it later which I have here with me.

When Evan Roberts was already retiring from publicity, just because he felt it was not of God that too munch interest and faith should centre in his personality, it was py-privilege to get x glim} mys@f of what—not Evan Roberts but—God was doing among the Welsh miners. I saw nothing hysterical. Between' the large public meetings I was taken by my hostess to cottage gatherings where the conversation of the group, young. and old, converts and established church-members alike, was almost entirely of "the Christ we forget" in theee days. The joy one and another expressed in the Lord's love and merey, in His Word and promises, I would now designate as & quickened consciousness of God and His favour, The frequent breaking into song was a natural Jaccompaniment there would be liar conscious. T look: laying the: contents of their treasure chest, assured that the same peace and joy Divine favour was also mine though I was not then opening my treasure chest to others' view. If I visited those same friends today and they hele up no spiritual possession joyfully for my view, T would not presume to imagine they had lost all such because the box was shut!

As to "the violent reaction toward the old Adam," I would like to know what foundation you have jin actual fact for such a sweeping: remark? Even if you could let me have conerete and numerous instances of "converts" who ha lapsed; drunkards gone back to worse drunkenness, etc., though 11 years in China have separated me from the Welsh friends I made then, T doubt not a short time for definite enquiries would bring more than enough of the opposite kind of evidence.

That among the masses who crowded to hear Evan Roberts or find vent for their new spiritual life in ecstatic song and testimony there were occasionally hysterical persons, I would not think of denying. Such would act hysterically in any extraordinary circumstances. To speak fairly of that or any revival one must be able to separate tthe incidental from the fundamental, As an eyewitness of some part of that wonderful time in Wales, I consider your reflexion on the out-Jcome of that revival is not justifi-

The unfortunate thing is, that ordinary readers will remember and quote the gist of that probably random remark as a verified, indi putable fact concerning the Welsh revival, meant to warn all and sundry against ever showing excitement or even credulity over the conversion of sinners in large numbers!

For the sake of such, will you Kindly grant me space for a little parable? There was gre-t commotion in a certain house one day. Happy laughter, jokes and congratulations mingled with the lusty cry of a healthy infant. There was (pardonable) excitement as an. important-looking nurse handed round the long-desired son and heir, while the young father arid proud and parents beamed with joy. Te was an extra-ordinary event in their family and even reserved natures expressed themselves with Enter the same house a few years later, No commotion; no bustling nurse; no neighbours with offers of help; no visiting relatives expressing satisfaction; no exeitement whatever! But the boy was thers!

Or a few years later still. Father perhaps knitting his brows as to how he can send his lad to college; mother wearing a shabbier gown because the son outgrows his clothes faster than they can buy new ones, grumbling maybe because he has torn his pants again or broken a window at his play. The life begun on that day amid excitement is there in stronger force and—despite "reactionary results" indicated—joy in the. boy is there in deeper measure, as any probing circumstance would discover.

"I know that whatsoever God Ecclesiastes 3: 14, While God's instruments are ings and "missions" of varied kinds.|faulty human beings, there are They recognized this as something certain to be excrescences not of God—including ex from merely scull from spiritual, enjoyment, course such will pass, Every religious movement, too, includes the temporary transform: tions of emotion, human resolution, physic influences, ete, which lacking Divine life, cannot last, OF course the subjects thereof sink even lower by way of re-action These should never be confounded with the quickening of the Holy Spirit into that life which has its root not in any religious exercises but in that gift of God to a perishing world which we have just been celebrating. "God hath given to us eternal life and this life is in His Son, He that hath the Son hath life and he that hath not the Son hath not life."

As to Gineral Feng and his 0 know anything of them' will grant' you the word (Happy China if such became her ordinary troops!) but I note that those of my personal friends who have spent time in his camp are the warmest believers. in and that none suggest anything "fanatical"—a much abused word—in the religious fervour they find there. The fact that General Feng: has from the first, and now me creasingly, desived not "missioners" but Bible teachers for his men, is strong safeguard against any sort of fanaticism. Does not the latter grow out of holding one particular doctrine or Scripture passage to the exclusion or the neglect of others? Christians nourished on the whole Word of God are not the kind from which fanatics are made, except in the opinion of those who consider any enthusiasm for God's kingdom and regard for His laws to be fanatical, General Feng's aim ix, 1 une derstand, a chaplain for every thousand men in his army and he is ill a long way from attaining that ideal at present, I believe, If anything arises akin to the possibilities you so gloomily sketched on Dec. 28, it is more likely to be from the little instruction these erstwhile idol worshippers have [cases received, than from doses of Christianity! have faith that God who has certainly worked among these soldfers as amongst the Welsh miners 20 years ago. will go on to "perfeet™ that which He has begun, KNOW that whatsoever GOD oath, it shall be for ever"

Tam, ete, Frances M. Boca *Miss Boyee's point of view makes it rather diffeult to enter into controversy with her and we will leave it with the assurance that the original: statement about a reaction after the revival -was not made unadvisedly. "As regards the name of the preacher we were, frankly, uncertain. There were no books we could consult. but we asked some Welsh friends. We thank Miss Boyce for the corree= tion—Ed.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account