The Archive · 1927

The Great Betrayal

To the Editor of the "NonrH-Cuina Datty News."

Sin,—As a London business man with long and intimate knowledge of China trade, paying frequent visits to China, permit me through your lumps fo express my thanks to Mr. Axthur de C. Sowerby for his very able article entitled "The Great Betrayal" which appears in your issue of to-day. It expresses my! own feelings to the letter; and I venture to think from my knowledge of the British community here, it expresses the feelings of the great! majority.

When the Hankow Agreement was signed, much as we realized the degradation of the thing, Aificult to increase wages or even: to maintain them at the existing Jevel. He stated that "the real evil from which almost all branches of _Andustry are suffering is the serious Jack of working capital, which is not auficient to allow of the increate of production in the prescribed pre Portion." Output must be increased more rapidly than wages. On the motion for the State regulation of wages, Comrade Tomsky stated that central Council of the unions Sowerby states, we looked for a qu had consistently acted on the in- pro quo with some safeguard dications of the Communist Party, and subordinated the interests of the British interests, There is no such safeguard in the terms of the Agree-workers to those of the State. ment now published, and it is be-

One delegate pointed out that! State regulation nullified the work of the unions, and went on to. state] that "the State fixes by decree the numbers and categories of employees each vadertaking, as well as the wage attached to each category. "it fig impossible for the trade union to discuss the matter, and the labour: agreement arrived at by free discussion ceases to exist." Another dele-ate complained that the manage-ament often demanded overtime working of @ ten-hour day and over without extra payment, "on the pretext that the law fixes wages once for alt without any reference to hours of work." In other eases, where the undertaking was in a position to inerence wages, the management said that the union was no longer con cerned with the wage question. As consequence, the authority of the unions waned, and, instead of seek-wage adjustments through the unions, the workers presented peti-Hions to the management "humbly re: questing that wages be increased. The union had not the power to defend the interests of the workers.

The statements made at this Con-wros raise c: rtain questions which might be studied by our Chinese! Friends with advantage, We have een led to believe that it is the dictatorship of the proletariat which rules the Soviet Republic. If that ig so why is it that the workers must present "p: titions," humbly request ing that wages be increased? If there is in Soviet Russia a real dictatorship of th: lat, don't the workers come that category?

For the past ton years the world das bein exhorted" ly Bolshevik emissaries to exterminate capitalists) ard capitalism. If there nese ary evils from which the world is suffering, how comes it that the "real evil" from which Bolshevik our prestige for a mess of pottage. The Agreement cannot and will not be worth the paper it is written upon: and it passes my comprehension how any British Government could have been made a party to so servile a document from such a chao-tie source, We already Rave the aftermath in the "Commission" which will presumably hand over the Tientsin Concession to the North, Could folly go further? Evidently force—only force—counts, on one British Prestige forsooth!! permit me to give another instance. A few! weeks ago I was in Hongkong. With] a friend late one evening I went on boatd a British steamer lying along-_ side the wharf. We were acconipanied by the engineer. The steamer flew the British flag, was officered by British officers, and was a British-owned vessel. To our utter indignation and disgust the boat was seething mass of propaganda for the Cantonese anti-British anti-foreign Nationalist party. Large and lurid] posters adorned the steamer inviting all and sundry to espouse the cause! of the so-called "Nationalists, "down with Imperialism," "Unite—Workers" ete., and other battle-cries so dear to the heart of the revolutionary. A mass meeting was being! held on board, and Chinese—both men and women—kept going anid coming as though they owned the ship.

On inquiry I was informed the owners had permitted this indecent] exhibition in order to obviate a stu and keep the steamer workin: There stood in the road near b swarthy Sikh policeman and 1 wondered what were his thoughts a:

stood and watched the strange! scene, What docs India think? The British Empire has surely sunk (9) 'a low ebb when it allows Chinese: coolies to run its ships xhle its

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account