The Archive · 1931

Private Detectives

Questions were raised by Mr. Is. "Lea, Assistant Municipal Ad: Ivocate,'in the Shanghai Special Dis. viet "Court before Judge Hsiao on July 18 as to whether or not per-Jsons operating in the International Settlement as private. detectives were authorized to make are without being armed with warrants issued by a proper law court and/or whether or not they were empowered use handeaf's when making rests, The case involved three an-

The three accused, according to police evidence, went to the house lof a Chinese at 428 Tongshan Road fon July 3 and demanded §25 and, when the Ghinese refused to pay, accused threatened to revert "16 violon"

'Complainant then report= Jed the matter to the Shanghai Protection and Investigation Bureau, a private detective agency," of which Mx. W. A, Rettig. was' manager. Mz. Reitig and three of his Chinese detectives" proceeded to complain-fant's house and arrested the three face used, handeusfed them end hand-[ed them over to the Municipal police, When the hearing was resumed yesterday, Mr. Rettig stated that Ihe and thee Chinese detectives went to complainant's house to investigate the affair and, under his direc~

He further stated three Chinese

leufts, astectives carried a. pair of hands Mr, Lea pointed out to the Court that, according to law, private a tactives had no authority to make arrests without first obtaining warrants from a proper law court, [Neither did private detectives, said [detective was sentenced by {to a term of imprisonment for lawfully handcuffing a person. In the present ease, the private dotece tives should not' have arrested the accused without a warrant special District Court, tated that, in crimine jai cases, his sole desire was to cooperate with the police in effecting ithe arrest of Criminals, Mx, Lea replied that, while the police very much appreciated the ce-opera tion of private detectives, the latter [must carry out their ce-operation fonly within the limits of the laws (Counsel then pointed out three factors in the present case, First, he id, why had complainant reported affair to IMr. Rettig's Protection land Investigation Bureau instead of to the Municipal Police? Secondly, why did Mr. Rettig not notify the police immediately' after he had received a report from complainant? Thirdly, why did the Chinese detec tives under Mr. Rettig carry handcuffs and assault one of the accused as alleged by the latter?

Dir, Rettig replied that complain-lant had reported the matter to his Bureau because he (complainant), had a friend who was working in ithe Bureau, As to the second point, witness stated that it was practice to make investigations in eases before reporting to the police because, if he were unable to find out anything in the case, it would be useless for him to report to the police, With regard to the third point, Mr. Rettig denied that ig detectives had assaulted one of ithe accused. When he and his de-actives arrived at complainant's thouse, he said, they saw complaine Jant assault one of the accused.

At this juncture, a further remand was ordered,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account