The Archive · 1931

By 0. M. Green Special to the Nec, Herald

speech made by Cardinal HBcurne, the Gatholic Archbishop of Westminster, at Edinburgh on J has made a great stir, His] Eminence criticized the Church England for being apathetic, for showing" a went of sympathy on moral questions such as birth prevention and divorce," and he includ-fed the Conservative Party in his feriticism as being most closely associated with the Church of Eng-snd.

He criticized the Liberals, the representatives of Nonconformists, fand quoted a remark of Sir Henry [Campbell-Bannerman's, 25 years in the religious fight that raged round the schools, that the Liberals had been put into power by the Noneon-{fermists and must legislate accordingly. "ive Labour Party, Cardinal Bourne let down rather lightly. Possibly he did not. wish to goad them too far after the recent Papal Encyclical declaring that a Chris-Tian cannot bea Socialist. The whale of his speech suggested an in-Rentional corollary to. the Eneyel Jminate against one party, and that} jallare open to its rebuke, But there has been a variety of unhappy little disputes between Anlglicans and Catholics. Some few months ago there was a very unfweleome controversy between Dr. David, the Anglican Bishop _of [Liverpool, and the Catholic Archbishop, over a charge made by! Dr. David that Catholic priests had! fbecn telling women of their flock, who had married men of other. faiths, that they were living in sin their children were illegitimate. {fe must be admitted that Dr. David Jspoke rashly and got the worst of} it in the argument.

Catholic speakers, too, Ihave denounced the apparent uncertainty of Anglican clergy on the question of birth control; about, Jwhich the Catholic Church' has no doubt whatever:

But Cardinal Bourne has farther than any and his high posltion naturally adds to the force of his remarks. It would be interest ling to know exactly why he spoke jin this way, at a time when there is quite enough discord. T add the report from the "Times," as many! [people will be interested in it:

Cardinal Bourne said the Catholic Church as such had nothing whatever to do with any political party. Like her Divine Master and Founder Jshe had never enunciated a scheme lof polities. There was nothing in {the Gospel which told them to which political party they ought to belong.

In considering the three parties must never be forgotten that no catholic could ally himself to any Jone of them absolutely and entirely. They were largely composed those who did not share his Catholic Faith. They did not pretend to loccept the teaching or the brit jof the Church. Many members of [them were directly opposed to her be generally admitted, "that the Conservative Party is in closer and more intimate contact with the Established Church Jof England than either of the other political parties. I regret to have observed how very apathetic the Church of England often appears in aiding those interests about which the Catholic Church is deeply concerned. We find very often, among] Jour Anglican friends, a want of sympathy on moral questions, such jas birth prevention and divorce, which astonishes us.

"The same may be said of the jechool question. The Church of England gives us little encourage-iment when we are fighting that} Inever-ceasing struggle for the nonprovided schools. By its readiness {to surrender schools it weakens the detective story and a the reputation of Mr. Edgar Wallace which make Chinese bandits feel they are missing something as long! as they do not know English, it is gratifying, and abates. a little the edge from their atrocities, to find Willingness to learn among people whom neither the Board of Educa-Non nor the National Union of Teachers would have ventured, even their most sanguine and' Napoleonic moments, to include among. hole position, To my mind the (Conservative leadership of the touse of Lords on the occasion of fine recent' Education. Bill was plorable inefficient, and it was une redeemed by any efficient, Anglican faction. A" great. opportunity establishing a just principle was Host' by political manceuvring. some matters the Church of Engs and is not only not helpful, but dee finitely unfair and unfriendly, Time after time leaders. in the Chure Jot England have not refrained from Imiaking unfounded charges against Ihe Catholic Church with regard declarations of nullity, and have not hesitated to insinuate that the fiudicial tribunals of the Catholfa [Church are influenced in such mate ters by purely mercenary motives, These false statements have beet refuted again and again with the statement of the true facts."

They had proved over and over again their enrive willingness to da

national cause. Too often the their power to help any traly peal for joint action was based not fon any definite principle, but on feague appeal to sentiment, "Ar regards the Liberals, the dif culty seemed still greater, They Jeould not forget. the events of 25 years ago, when an enormous Tiberal majority was used in a pro longed endeavour to do permanent injury to the cause of definite rey ligious teaching. He particulary jealled the day when he saw Siz ienry.\ Campbell-Bannerman—a ost charming person—who receive fed him with every kindness and cons sideration, and spoke to. him with such frankness that until: that day, he had hesitated to make public his illuminating, remarks. pointed out to him," he said, "that the Government" would inflict orions injury on the most, sacred interests of the Catholic, Church, replied very simply: We have been put into power by the Noneom armists, and we must produce legislation that will satisfy the

gone|efforts, can bring about a' chan; Nenconformiats, If you by, your Dublie' opinion, then we shall. ate prepared to aller our attitude." Tam very much afraid [that the Nonconformist influence still very hostile to our Catholig schools, and. that, that influence is still potent in what, remains of a lureat political party'

"Now to pass to the Labour Party." Doubtless we shall. find therein some whove opinions are nob fin"'accordance with the teaching lund principles "of the Catholic [Church. 1 suppose there are some who say that they are Socialists in Ithe technical sense—a thing which Ino. true Catholic can bern Thus There, too, a Catholic is obliged to lvalk' warily, and, while accepting ina general' sense the policy of the purty to which he belongs, must learefully guard himself against. any, theory or action which contradicts Ithe teaching of "the Church, oF which is contrary to the dictates of his own conscience."

Referring to. previous expressions lof opinion by himself that a Cath lie might belong to any: one of the lrarties, he said he thought the One leyelical, if he understood it, righto fally, fully confirmed what he had lalvendy said, He had called attend ition to the fact that few members lof the Labour Party, and certainly, ino Catholic member of that party} would deny the right of private ownership or preach class: warfare; the two points generally associated with Socialism. The Holy Fathet Jiad given a deeper analysis of: Socialism than. this by indicating that the two errors were symptoms [of the disease rather than the dis" order itself, Only six states—Argentina, Brasil, Ecuador, San and. Uruguay—out' of, 68 invited by the United States Gove ernment to accede to the Kelloge Pact, have not yet done so. Cere Hain'steps have been taken by, the Bolivian Government but they have been ratified yet. i The International: Association for rubber growing in the Netherlands East. Indies is, shortly forming a committee for the reorganization of the industry: The President will be Professor Van Iterson and the mem= bers, Mr. Loudin Burger of Amsterdam, Baron Van Lijnden, and Messrs Van' Den Bosch, Fatman, Greiner, Koei, and-Kasteleyn.of The Tague,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account