The Archive · 1921

A Fair Test

Two members of my—staff—both experienced teachers—at once fell in with my suggestion to try simplified spelling for a certain period, and they undertook the work. Two other teachers kindly gave up their classes for reading, in order that the experiment might be completed in the shortest time possible. Both teachers have given two world-building lessons each morning—to one class on the orthodox method and to the other class on the simplified spelling plan. In this way we hoped to arrive at as fair and true a comparison as could possibly be obtained'—the classes being composed of children of the same type, taught by the same teachers, under similar circumstances, and in the same surroundings.... We are fully convinced that learning to read on the simplified spelling plan is much the happier experience for a little child at the beginning of its schoo] career, because, as each symbol always represents the sane sound, the child is not disappointed or confused by continual failure to pronounce the printed word correctly; neither is he afraid to attempt unfamiliar words. As the children are compelled to read English as it is printed and to write it as it is spelt, it necessary to devote time to the transition stage, which, so far as we can judge, after the first few lessons that the older children have received, gives promise of presenting fewer difficulties and occupying less time than we anticipated."

No Conrusine Rvtes.

Regarding the actual method of teaching, there is little to say here—tho ordinary rules of the Simplifield Spelling method of teaching English are followed: a simplified method, with only one short group of vowel sounds, and no bunches of confusing rules and rule excep-Hons to confuse young minds. The tinies are {taught first of all by means of simplified spelling, which they afterwards characterize as "the baby way."

The transition stage carries them to "the big people's way" of spelling, when crime" becomes "cumd," "duz'" becomes ''does," and so on and so forth. The teachers at Honeywell Road find that the children master the transition stages quickly and easily and it is unusual for a child to get confused between the "simplified'' and the "ordinary" ways of spell ling.

Children who: have been trained on these lines read with remarkably good expression and understanding.

There is no doubt that the Honey-well infants just love their reading lessons in a way that many school-children do not—most especially do they love them when the "strict" part of the lesson is over and they can go to the library cupboard and choose from it what book they like for the remainder of the time. 2

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account