To the Editor of the "Norta-Caixa Dairy News."
Str,—I have been hoping thit someone Would take up the "milk" question but I have waited in vain. This cannot be due to lack of interest for it is probably one of the most vital points so far as health is concerned this city has to face and the sooner it really faces it the better.
This morning's paper reports that a dairy at 815 Gordon Road was fined $100 for adulteration of milk, this apparently being the maximum fine. Is this sufficient to deter milk adulteration I most. emphatically state, No. This particular dairy, I am told, owns 69 animals, yielding approximately close on 700 bottles of milk per day, or, to be on the safe side, say 600. The value of this milk is roughly $100 per day and it is a simple calculation to work out what profit 68 per cent. adulteration of the milk means and, to realize what a paltry punishment a fine of $100 is to the owner of this particular dairy.
I enclose a statement which I have prepared based on extracts from two recent Municipal Gazettes of March 10 and April 14, givin! details of adulterations of—mili from licensed dairies examined in the Municipal laboratories. Taking the individual offenders appearing in these two Gazettes and referring to their past unenviable records, I think everyone will be amazed at the number of convictions recorded against certain of these dairies. T have not been able to go through the Municipal Gazettes thoroughly and have perhaps omitted.certain cases but for all practical purposes the statements serve their purpose and if they are not absolutely correct err in favour of the dairy owners, Unsigned letters to the press have undoubtedly a-value in influencing public opinion but I de not think that this will be necessary in this case and I urge upon those who are really interested in the health of this Settlement, particularly those with families, to act and act at once, and to put into motion some power which w improve our milk supply and prevent it being utilized as a means of swindling and robbery at the expense of the lives of those dear to us. I have no axe to grind—I do not now buy my milk from any dairy, but I do not think foreign residents quite appreciate the condition of the dairies and the condition of their milk supply generally. In the house the matter is left more or less to servants, householders in the majority of cases consoling themselves merely by close supervision on the question of boiling the milk.
I urge that at the earliest possible date a commission should be formed thoroughly to investigate the entire milk question, consider carefully the by-laws and every other detail appertaining to guaranteeing a pure milk supply and the general keeping of cattle in Shanghai and in_ particular provide that the punishment for adulteration or other offences should, after three convictions, be cancellation of licences and not an absurd fine, regarded as it is at the moment, as a regular "working expense" by dishonest dairy keepers.
I am, etc., Percy Fowzer. Shanghai, April 21.
Menicipat Gazerre Darep APRIL
14, 1921.
Dairy Hong Yuen, Soong Yuin-kyung, 10? Jessfield Road 14/4/21 Adulteration 43.6 % added water 14/4/21 oe 38.25% 5 Previous records show 17/7/19 Adulteration 8.3 % added water Dairy Loong Dah, Tso Zing-shing, 51 Ferry "Road 14/4/21 Adulteration 8.249% added water Previous records show: 2214/20 22/4/20 Adulteration 35.2 % added water
Dairy Bubbling Well Road, "K. C. Sung. R100 Carter Road 14/4/21 Adulteration 3.5 9 added water Previous records showing' same name but address as 160 Bubbling Well 11/2/15 Adulteration 23.0 % added water
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.