The Archive · 1921

The Right to Retaliate

Dr. Hugh Bellot, the well-known jurist, delivering an address to the Grotius Society recently on the "Right of a Belligerent Merchantman to Attack,'' protested against the findings of the German Commission of Inquiry on the execution of Captain Fryatt.

Briefly, he said, the Bruges Court-martial held that when signalled by the U 33 to stop Captain Fryatt refused, and tried to ram the submarine. This they considered unlawful, and they condemned Fryatt to death as a franc-tireur. Such a thing at sea was purely a German conception, said Dr, Betlot, a creature of German municipal law never recognized in international law nor adopted in practice. He laid down the proposition that not only was it permissible for the merchant vessels of a belligerent country to resist, by force, visit and subsequent search by enemy warships, but also for them to attack enemy warships or merchantmen without being treated as pirates. In the Eighteenth and early Nineteenth Centuries practically all merchantmen trading to the Near and Far East were armed offensively, without assuming any privateering functions.

The Court-martial on Captain Fryatt was not a properly constitute ed Naval Court, so Admiral von Schréder, who was responsible and refused to postpone the execution' and all those who constituted the Court were guilty df a judicial mur der. That such persons might on the conclusion of peace be tried and punished was clearly established.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account