China on Tuesday Judge Lobingier gave his decision on a demurrer raised by the defendants in an action at the instance of L. van der Stegen against Neuss, Hesslein Ca., Inc. Mr. J. B. Davies appeared on behalf of the demurrants, and Mr. James Ress was for the plaintiffs.
Judge Lobingier's decision on the demurrer was as follows Defendant demurs to a_ petition alleging That on or about January 3, 1920, the Belgian Trading Ca. entered into a contract with the defendant whereby the defendant purchased from the Belgian Trading Ca. and the Belgian Trading Ca. sold to the defendant 100 tons spray hen's egg yolk at gold $0.54 per Ib. net C. I. F. New York, shipment April to June, 1920, and 75 tons hen's egg album men at gold $1.28 per Ib. C. I. F.. New York, shipment April to July, 1920.
And a memorandum of said contract was duly made and signed by the said defendant which said memorandum hereunto annexed and marked "plaintiff's exhibit A" and made a part of this petition and said contract was duly confirmed in writing by plainting on January 31, 1920 a copy of which said writing is hereunto annexed and marked "plaintiff's exhibit B" and made a part of this petition." (Par. 4).
There is no averment it will be observed that the contract itself is set forth in the petition or attached thereto but merely that "a memorandum of said contract" and the confirmation thereof are separately annexed. In other words the petition alleges that the parties "entered into a contract"; that "said contract was duly confirmed in writing by plaintiff"; and that memorandum of said contract was duly made and signed" and "is hereunto annexed." It is nowhere alleged that either the memmorandum or the confirmation sct out the entire terms of the contract and for aught that appears the former may be no more than the memorandum which is required in order to satisfy the Statute of Frauds. The authorities cited counsel for demurrant to the effect that where a copy of the contract or an instrument containing its entire terms is set forth the Court will not look further is therefore inapplicable.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.