The Archive · 1931

Then and Now

July 29.

From the dazzling figure of the exotic Disraeli to the gor-geons impressiveness of the Scottish Labour Prime Minister, Ramsay MacDonald the the historian has to travel with agility and endurance. The Treaty of Berlin signed to complete the Berlin Congress 01 July 13, 1878 was framed to re tore the balance of power in Europe, unsettled by the Russ Turkish conflict. Lord Beacons field's success at the Congress phrase, with which he was garlanded on his return to London.

'A com mentary declared England, Berlin was like the reclamation of butter from a dog's mouth; as Prince Bismarck understood" in acknowledging, Disracli's gitts of It should be remembered that Beaconsfield's triumph paved the way for a policy which actually was never put into operation but the influence on the Congress on Subsequent events in Europe will be generally recognised. The development of the Triple Alliance against France and Russia was one of its carly aftermaths, growing, as it directly did, from the formal defensive Alliance between Germany and Austria in the following year. In seme respects the problems which Mr. MacDonald has to face in Berlin are very different from those of 53 years ago. In the main the issue is financial. But in the background, ageres-ly ready to "take stage" are the political differences which bear a family resemblance to the old questions relating to the preservation of the power in Europe, 'A link too may be teand with those Victorian days in the ery of London to the returning Prime Minister. Just over a hundred years earlier a chronic der, writing of the disastrous policy of James LI said "He had rather spend £10,000 on Embassien, to Keep or _procare peace with dishonour™ than £70,000 on an army that would have forced peace with honour."

The eighteenth century acclaiming a diplomatic triumph evidently judged these issues from the point of view of the criticism ed James. Its twentieth century successor would go further. Victorian England of 1878 was eager for peace, The Napoleonic Wars had Jeff behind a tradition which first finds expression in Earl Grey's declared programme of "Retrenchment, Reform and Peace" for 1880.' John Bright made the triple watchword his own in 1869 at Birmingham. So it is not too extravagant to detect im the verbal bouquet thrown at Beaconfield yet another rendering of the same d sire. It is indeed one of history' remarkable faculties for repeating itself that this visit of Mr. Ramsay MacDonald to Berlin should have for its immediate precedent the electrical vision of Beaconsfield in 1878, It would be difficult to deny that in 1931 the state of Europe is as critical as it was in 1878. The personalities of the two men are different, Beaconsfield was a popular idol; he was also the subject of grave distrust and, even, hatred in the ranks of the party he led and of the party which opposed him, Mr. Raisay MacDonald creates no violent animosity. He has his hero-worshippers but even his own followers find him at tim aloof and inscrutable. He possesses the strong egoism to which Beaconsfield was also victim but he tacks the sense of humour of the Jew. To set off against these d fects, the Prime Minister hi an exceptionally wide grasp of foreign policy. He has the knack of seeing through the glasses of the other nation. Abroad, however restrained may be his countrymen's appreciation of him at Home, he is recognized as a fully competent spokesmen of the nation, His visit to Berlin is easentially a motional adventure. The German Government are too wise to read too much into it. The recent discussions in Paris and London must have con: vinced them that British friendship for Germany will not be a fontered at the expense of the Sir. MacDonald's past speeches entente with France. Ind

ave any guide, it would. seem that he sees the role of mutual friend as most approxi to Great Britain's relation with: the two great countries acrons the North Sea and the Channel. Mr, MacDonald has begun well with a reference to the repair tions issue. There can be little doubt that whatever was dia-appointing in the London Conference was due to the fact that it: was impossible fairly and squarely to face that issue, The key lies in hands other than those of Great Britain and France, Signs of a conviction that it must eventually be put into operation are. multiplying. President Hoover" ssture itself confirms that view. Of this Berlin meeting much in the immediate will not be expected. It is unlikely that Mr. Mac-Donald will be greeted from packed balconies on his return to London. That it may do a great deal to add strength to the movement for European cooperation is the chief hope of the world. It must be recognised that, until Europe shows a capacity for consolidating peaceful ties and for guarding aguinst the violent expression of national enmities, it is impossible to expect others to join in the task of relief,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account