practical, immediate portance the independence or otherwise of the Philippine Tslands may not be of the first moment to us here in China. The repercussion, however, which any change in status there would have upon the whole of the East is so great that sooner or later its effect would come home to us. Within fow months General Wood and Mr. Cameron Forbes will have a report to present to the United States legislature on the subject, but whatever the opinions they have formed, we may be certain that all manner of cross influences will be brought to bear upon those with whom the fate of the Islands rests. Men of affairs like the two gentlemen we have mentioned' are not likely to go very fur astray in their conclusions, especially with their already intimate knowledge of the country, but unfortunately there are others who can bring pressure ta bear; some, it may be, with personal ends to serve, others whose idealism outruns—their sense of practical values. Against their exertions on whichever side utilized, it is wise to be on guard, for the importance of the decision to be made is too great for it to be trifled with. Accordingly special attention should be devoted to one or two points in particular. The views of the inhabitants are at present being canvassed, and if ur information is accurate, a clear majority for any one policy will be difficult to find. On top of this there will be the question of the fitness of the Filipino for sclfgovernment, whether, in fact, he is able to stand on his own legs. Here some information is actual-of the Islands is an all-important point. 7
The latter is obviously a difficult question to answer. The politician, anxious to have the country in his own hands, will assuredly be able to point to work done, but against this can be quoted the views of many foreign residents that progress has been retarded since American control was relaxed and that the average inhabitant is not so comfortable as he was previously. The controversy is too wide andi the data at present too scant for us to enter into it, and we may, therefore, go on to mention an exceptionally interesting classification of opinion in the Philippines which is vouched for by one well acquainted with the Islands. Four sections of opinion at present exist, one or two of which may surprise the outsider. The perfervid politician, who flourishes. healthily in these climes, constitutes a large proportion of the independents, and as will be seen later, this school of thought cannot be said to differ materially from the people favouring a protectorate under the United States. Then there are those who favour a continuance of the Tslands under full) American rule, undoubtedly an influential body, for we have been told that many, while expressing divergent views in public, have privately informed the American commissioners of their real sentiment. A third class is said to favour Spain, nor is this surprising, for in parts of the community of all countries deep-rooted conservatism is to be found, clinging to the regime of a former day, handed down through even many generations. What may, however, be matte: for surprise is that a section of the young Filipinos is said to favour the Japanese. They seem to recognize an affinity between the two peoples, and doubtless before them rise visions of a great 1921. Takis 12 PER ANNUM.
Eastern people, of which many have talked in the past. Between all these grades of opinion the inquirer will find difficulty in laying hold of any definite workable majority such as could claim control of the country's destinies, From the effects which dependence would be likely to have on other countries.in the East, the opinion which must principally concern us is that of the independence party. Without any hesitation we may put their standpoint down as thoroughly unsatisfactory, and failing to fulfil the condition which we noted that the country should be able: to stand on its own legs. The suggestion put forward by the independents is that a period, five years for instance, should be granted to them to experiment in the art of self-government. Tt at the end of that time they are found to have failed, the United States Government will come in and straighten out matters. Some even go further than that, they wish to be independent for all time, but if they make a mess of their finances they would have America come to their assistance, and, if embroiled with or threatened by any other Power, America would protect them against aggression. That a practical country such as America should even listen to such a suggestion is unthinkable. The United States might very properly warn off all other countries with covetous eyes on the Islands, but could hardly take upon herself the full eleemosynary role which is suggested. Unfortunately the matter does not end with that statement. The Roman Catholic Church in the Philippines is understood to favour independence, and it is reported that a large section of the other denominations adopts a similar attitude. This means a very great influence in America in the direction of independence, no matter how conclusive the arguments may be on the other side. Against their. better judgement, unfortunately, politicians of all shades of opinion have at times
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.