The hearing was commenced in the Shanghai Provisional Court Inst Thursday and Friday, of Holger Harrendorf, a German subject, who is charged with obtaining by tale pretences, and/or by utter= ing or conspiring to utter false invoices, from various banks in Shanghai a sum exceeding £100,000, Counsel appearing in the case ure: for the Hongkong & Shanghai Bank, Mr, J. E. Badeley of Messrs. Hansons; for the Chartered Bank of India Australia and China, Mr.
Platt of Messrs. Platt & Cos fcr the Deutsch Asiatische Bank and the Chekiang Industrial Bank, Dr. 0, Fischer; for the National Commercisl & Savings Bank, Mir. A, Y, Ting; and for the defendant, Mr. N.F. Allman, Dr, P: Wilhelm holdy a watching brief for certain employees of Harrendort & Ca. and Mr, C, S, Franklin for Mr.
Fonseca, the manager of the firm, 'Mr, Badeley, in opening the case, enid that the' charge involved extensive frauds, extending over a period of nearly two years, by! means of which the firm of Tarrendorf & Ca., in conjunction with the firm of Muench & Wecker, of Hamburg, obtained advances. from the banks ostensibly to finance shipments of goods which, according to the invoices supplied to the banks, contained valuable cargoes of elastics, silks and other goods, Dut in fact only contained very cheap glass tumblers, The loss which the Hongkong & Shanghai Bank "had suffered from "these frauds amounted to approximately £54,000, There were other charges pending by the other banks who have been similarly defrauded, and cher the losses amounted. to over, £100,000, of Harrendorf & Ca. sen charg it. J. P. Fonceea, the manager with complicity in the frauds before the Portuguese court, and tad been committed for trial in Macao, while the partners in the firm of Muench & Wecker had been arrested by the Hamburg authori ties, and were awaiting trial there.
The. system of working the frauds was that Harrendorf & Ca. would apply to the Hongkong Bank to open a credit in favour of Muench Weeker to finance the importation of a cargo of valuable merchandise. to Shanghai, Muench Weeker would (apparently) chip the goods, and would present to the Hamburg branch of the Hong-Kong Bank a bill of exchange drawn upon Harrendort & Cou, together with complete shipping documents, namely a bill of ladi insurance policy and invoice, which would be for, say, two or three cases of elastics (or other goods) Valued st about £195, In fact the eases contained only cheap tumblers worth about £4 the case, The Uccuments would be sent out to the Hongkong Bank, and the bill of exchange would be presented to the insisted in-coming back,' His|Harrendorf & Ca., and accepted by them payable 90' days after sight. Upon the arrival of the goods, yendorf & Ca. would apply to the Hongkong Bank for the bill of lading in order to pass the goods through the customs, signing an undertaking to store the goods thereafter in the name of the bank. Harrendorf & Ca, would then hand! to th customs brokers the bills of lading, together with an which they had received direct from Muench & Wecker showing the real contents of the cares, namely tumblers, (but correspon ing with the marks on the cases appearing on the invoices handed to the bank with the documents at Hamburg) and the goods would be passed through the customs (es tumblers) and stored in the name of the bank, Before the bill of exchange fell due Harrendorf Ca, would apply to the bank to open a new credit in favour of Muench & Weeker, who would repeat the proce and would obtain from the bank at Hamburg a vances to the amount of the new credit on the security of similar invoices. Muench & Weeker would then remit by T. T. through the Yokohama Specie" Bank Marrendort & Ca. enough money' to take up and pay for the previous Dill of exchange, and: the latter would then take' delivery of the goods. The point to be noted is that as long as Harrendorf & Ca., bills of exchange the bank never casion to open the ca: never know whether they in fact contained what they were supposed to contain. When, however, as ultimately happened, the bank refused to allow Harrendort & Ca. to open new credits, Muench Weeker were unable to- telegraph out enough money to Harrendorf Ca. to take up. the outstanding! bills, " Consequently' the bank op ed the eases in their charge, and found that, out of 400 cases' sup~ posed to contain goods to the value of £61,000, practically all contained only cheap glass tumblers which were practically unsaleable.
Counsel then read a number of extracts from letters between Har-render! & Ca. and Muench Weeker which were found in " safe in Harrendorf's office.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.