The Archive · 1927

FOREIGN CHILD'S NARROW ESCAPE

the Provisional Court © ouf Thursday afternoon, before Judge Zin and My. A, Tajima (Senior Con sul's Deputy)" Tsang Ming-gee, a Chinese lawyer, was, summonned' by the Shanghai Municipal Police with having driven a motor ear negligently an April 29, at 11.45 acm, Mr. J. R, Jones appeared for the defendant.

C. 1867 stated that he was on point duty at the comer of Nanking Road and Szechuen Road fon the morning in question and de-caribed how the defendant's cur had entered Szechuen Rond from Nan~ King Road, and near the island, had struck a Chinese amah carrying a foreign child, knocking the amah down, seriously injuring her and causing the child to be thrown from the amah's arms into the roadway, 'After Mr, J. R, Jones had completed his' cross-examination of witness, the Judge intimated that under the terms of the rendition agreement, a foreign lawyer could not roprerent, the defendant in this action, Mz, Jones, while accepting ruling, asked that Howed to see aa copy of was handed to him. copy, The case then proceeded, Within three or four minutes, "Mr. Jones rose and addressed the court, pointing out a clause in the agreement which per= mitted a foreign lawyer to represent 'a Chinese defendant when the police twere the complainants, Judge Zia studied the clause and then reversed his decision, remarking that it would be in order for Mr. Jones to proceed on behalf of his client, Mr. George Arthur of Messrs. Mustard & Ca. said that he w standing on Whiteaway's corner and saw defendant's ear strike the amah twice, First with the right mud+ guard and then with the left, Witness was of opinion that fendant had put his foot on the wee celerator in mistake for the clutch, The amah was very badly injured, sustaining " broken leg and a broken arm and witness took her to the hospital. The baby (who is the two year old son of Mr, and Mrs, E, R, James) was thrown about 16 feet and escaped with a bruised farm, Witness said that the second time the car (which was a light Mathis) struck the amah, her body prevented the car from proceeding further. Defendant then backed out and proceeded to the kerb, Under cross-examination,—witness insisted that the ear had struck the amah twice, It was miraculous how the child escaped with comparatively also gave defendant gave evide He said that the dashed out from the pa ment and he could not avoid strike ing He had written a letter the hospital sympathizing with the amah and offering to pay her hospital expenses but insisted that the accident was her own' fault, Mr. Jones briefly addressed—the court, saying that there was no evi" dence to show that his client was anying carelessly or negligently o Jat an excessive speed immediately before the accident. After review ing the evidence, counsel asked that [the case be dismissed.

Judge Zia was of opinion that defendant had driven negligently and imposed a fine of $25,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account