The Archive · 1927

Mr, Millard Blows Off Steam

Nov. 14)

Our attention has just bee called to an article in "Asia, a monthly magazine published in New York, by Mr. Thomas F, Millard, which contains more misrepresentation and pompous, ex*eathedra nonsense than anything that we have seen in print for a long while. The article} is entitled "Undermining Our} Chinege Policy," with the subtitle "American Officials in China and. the Department of State at Cross-Purposes." It is very largely an attack on Mr. MacMurray -and the American Legation, sometimes open and sometimes covert; though certain unnamed Consular officials, the American Chamber of Commerce, and the American com-ition of policy. As one of the several Senators who was recently in-China remarked: "If they] can't trust in the judgment of the man: they have on the spot, why don't they send some one they can trust,"

The long account of a Minister's duties is designed to lead up to an attack on Mr. Mac-'Murray which, when it comes, is not direct but is implied. He first says that American. official dom and American commercial] organizations in China have, for the past two years, been in dissent from the policy of the American Government. Then, in ithe next paragraph, without connecting link, he tells who Mr. MacMurray is. He then proceeds to tell how American policy is opposed to the enforce. ment of treaty stipulations—which we cannot remember having seen so clearly munity in China at large come in for their share of denunci tion, The article is adorned with a few photographs. The first two show American marin marching on their drill gran in, the Legation. Quarter in Peking and other heavily armed marines at the steel gates at the west end of Legation Street. This is American Imperialism, no.doubt, Next comes a picts of. Mr. MacMurray, the villain in the piece, Then come the two e:. Randall Gould, Peking cor-heroes and martyrs of the story,

spondent for the United Press, and Mr. J, B. Powell, editor of the."China Weekly Review." Mr. Gould is shown conversing with Dr. C. C, Wang and Mr. H. H. Kung. Under Mr. J. B. Powell's likeness is this title: B. Powell, editor of a too liberal journal, was asked to resign from the American Chamber of Commerce, in Shanghai." Under the group which includes Gould it is told how he was debarred from Legati conferences because publicity. to embarrassing incidents, refused to submit despatches to the Legation and w unsympathetic. Both these gentlemen are described as staunch supporters of the American Government's benevolent policy in China who have een victimized by the off and commercial folk in China simply because of their loyalty.

To get down to the article; itself, it opens with the statement' that America's established policy in China has frequently been in danger of relegation "It weathered very lately," says Mr. Millard, "by a narrower margin. than is generally understood in America, another! crisis." He predicts that an even more critical period is probably} coming. Most Americans here will join us in hoping that he is right. Following this overture, the author devotes quite a lot of space to defining the proper functions of a diplomat as he sees them. He says they ai dual: to promote good feeling and to carry out the specific Policies of his government. We should like to add that in our estimation an equally important one, if not the most important} of all, is that of Keeping the! Home' government—accurately informed upon changing conditions and to advise, with some confidence that his' advice -will jocked the Chinese were when the American Legation in Peking' seemed. to lose sight of this fundamental principle of American policy and continued to be guided by the old idea of adherence to the treaties. The Chinese inteitigentsia, regardless of party, he says, are determined change the treaties and, expected American support. This is probably true, but Mr. Millard ed by powerful feeling among] the masses." This we know is rubbish, and poisonous rubbish, because the one outstanding feature of this.situation is that} the vociferous demands' that go abroad for this or that "right' come from the classes that exploit the people and do not emanate from the Chinese people. The masses are even more densely ignorant of the substance of the treaties than the so-called intelligentsia, and the most significant feature of this situation is that popular antiforeignism swells up into a Jgreat roar of demands and protests as the "Ni advance into any given territory} and dies out absolutely when the patriots perforce depart. The} mob howls slogans and catch phrases under dictation to please the new masters and then goes placidly and thankfully back to! work when the new masters take themselves off.

Mr. Millard next turns his fire upon the British press in China. He has nothing to say on hi own account but he quotes a long paragraph from a_ report} by Colonel L'Estrange Malone, about whom the less said the better, and a short paragraph from Mr. L. A. Lyall's famous address in Shanghai at the end Jof 1926. Shanghai readers need no guidance in their appraisement of the value of these authorities. Much space is then given to proving that the Boxer Protocol is now obsolete and that the precautionary. stipul tions, such as keeping up garrisons in Peking and keeping the railway open to the sed, "are absurd in this era, He makes sport of the international military trains that run to and fro on the. Peking-Mukden line in war-time; and then comes to the "Taku Incident" of the Spring of 1926 and perpetrates some of his choicest misinter-he: accepted, upon the modifica-in, policy, which: new, peditions dictate! A Minister Pretatione. of facts.

willie: remembered that few Fengtien gunboats appeared

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account