June 18.
On Monday the British Imperial Conference is to begin in London, and to-day's telegrams tell us, what has been growing increasingly evident by all recent news, that the Anglo-Japanese Alliance will be amongst the most important of its agenda. A variety of opinions on this subject has been set before us. The Dominion Premiers insist that the Empire must be guided largely by the attitude of America. They feel that in many respects their own interests in the matter are largely identical with American and they are resolved that there shall be no check to mutual understanding for the sake of a country with which they find themselves incurably at variance on economic grounds, principally that of the admission of Oriental immigrants. There are those, also, who urge that China has a right to be consulted: we shall hear more of them when Parliament discusses the Alliance. The' Chinese attitude we know: it was well put in Dr. F. C. Tong's letter to us on Thursday and may be summarized thus: Renew. the Alliance by all means if you wish, but let it contain no reference of any kind to China."' FFinally there are the views of British merchants in this country; and the question is whether these have been properly represented at Home. Inasmuch as British merchants here are the first to be affected, they have surely the right to be heard.
There is little doubt but that Dr. Tong's letter represented the feeling not only of Chinese, but of a very large number of British residents in China. The latter may be subject to fits of irritation with what appears to them to be the slowness and inefficiency of Chinese ways especially in the management of their country's affairs. They may consider that telegrams sent indiscriminately abroad by Chinese mercantile bodies on a political question are in the nature of an impertinence. But at bottom they like the Chinese, they sympathize with China and they feel that she has had much to put up with from Japan. That feeling is shown in the strong demand that the Alliance shall only be renewed on clear conditions that will be as satisfactory to China as to Great as to Great Britain. But here is the difficulty: if those conditions are to be secured, how is it possible to frame them without allusion to China? Furthermore there has to be considered not only the advantage that can be obtained from renewal—such as the redressing of complaints, guarantees for the future and the general benefits of cooperation—but also the evil that would very probably ensue from its denunciation. For the ''loss of face' to Japan would be tremendous, and this could hardly fail to strengthen the chauf yinists, drive Japan into antagonism to everybody, cause her to quit the Consortium and lead to just the perils for this country which the Chinese merchants anticipate from an alliance renewed. Finally it may be asked how far America can really be studied in respect of renewal? And how far could she, or would she be willing to express acquiescence_in it without actually appearing to be a partner? She may feel that, in view of the rooted Chinese opposition to the Alliance, she cannot take any notice of the discussions concerning it without compromising herself in Chinese eyes in a way that would be the negation of her continually professed policy.
The answer to all these difficulties appears to lie only along the way suggested by Mr. G.jReuter.
H. Fairchild, who, there is reason to think, voices the opinion of influential people in Washington. His theme, it will be remembered, was the joint responsibilities of Great Britain and America for the peace of the Far East, as indeed throughout the world. He admitted that the Anglo-Japanese Alliance had produced good results, but he also thought it impossible to deny that it had contributed to results not at all good; nor did he think it possible to renew it in any form that would be acceptable to the peoples of China and America. Equally, however, does Mr. Fairchild dislike the Lansing-Ishii Agreement, which gave great umbrage in China; and he summed up his conclusions thus:
The time has arrived when there* should be a readjustment of understanding as to China's future, politically as well as commercially, and it is thought by many publicists that the nullification of the Anglo-Japanese Alliance, as well as the Lansing-Ishii Agreement, would clear the field for a new understanding between the three great maritime Powers, which would meet the situation and allay the suspicions of the Chinese.
In other words a Pacific Conference in which China would obtain the clearest representation of her views with equal understanding of those of others. Such an arrangement would, we believe, be welcomed as much by the best opinion in Japan as by other participants, and the way to it is certainly being smoothed by the promising negotiations between Japan and America regarding Yap and Shantung. We venture to suggest that the British Chamber of Commerce and China Association might well consider the advisability of endorsing this plan.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.