The Archive · 1927

The Statement of Dr

c Cc. WU

Nov. 2

The statement issued by Dr. C.

Wu from Nanking on the invalidity of treaties and agreements which do not have the: concurrence of the stration which he repre:

Minister of Foreign Affairs, may read at first glance like a bit of characteristic "Nationalist" swagger and may be meant a grand gesture for the delectation of the Kuomintang rank and file, but if the reader will go into it carefully he will find that it provides for the foreigner in China a valuable safeguard against the misguided enthusiasm of Home Governments for conciliation. In his first paragraph Dr.Wu doos, of course, inveigh against the unequal treaties and promise their abrogation within the shortest possible peri This, of course, is purely a grand gesture and nothing more. No self-styled Government in China enjoys at} this moment even de facto recognition and such recognition tainly will not be extended to the Nanking regime by the major.

until certain scores such are settled. The denunciation of the treaties by a recognized Government would: be a very serious matter, but the repudiation of existing obligations by an organization whose status can only be described as! that of a {olerated usurper of would at once reduce that organization to the status of an outlaw clique, challenging world with intoler-impertinence. Dr. Wu knows that the "shortest pos-[sible period" within which the scan be modified, is the shortest period within which a responsible Government of China can be evolved which shows a willingness to execute old bargains and therefore a capacity' for assuming new responsibilities. Subsequent clauses of his statement, indeed, help guarantee that this shall be so, Tu his second paragraph, Dr. Wu says that those treaties and agreements whose term has expired have, as a matter of course, become null and void. Of course they do, but we can think of no treaty which has any really important bearing upon the status of the foreigner in. China, nor upon the safeguards to com-. merce, life, and property, which has expired or can expire without negotiation between a representative, responsible, and recog nized Government of China and the foreign nation concerned. As we know from the altercation over the Belgian and Spanish treaties in Peking, some of the treaties, including the British treaty of 1858 provide for periodical revision of certain clauses pertaining to commercial and tariff matters. Such revision, however, cannot rightfully be carried out with a Government, called, which enjoys regional authority only and is challenge ed in all its acts by other regional Governments representing, after a fashion, the majority of the people and the greater part of the territory that used to be China, so there can be no question of any of the more portant treaties becoming null and void until it is jointly denounced by a genuine Chinese Government and the foreign Power concerned. Again, the regional administration that a tempts to denounce a treaty automatically outlaws itself before the world.

The two last paragraphs are, in our estimation, the important and valuable ones to us, for Dr. Wu says that no treaty or agreement signed by any Chinese authority without the participa tion or sanction of the '"Nationalists" will, in their estimation, have any validity or will be deemed binding on China, This is a fair warning which the "Nationalists", with their hopes of eventual national control, are fully entitled to issue, Tt is also a warning which Chang Tso-lin, with his hope of the eventual conquest of the whole of China's territories, is equally entitled to put forth; and we should be very pleased if he would emulate Nanking and do it, Perhaps he has already issued some such statement which we have overlooked.

At any rate the value of Dr.Wu's statement can be appreciated when it is remembered that in two very conspicuous instances in the past the announcement from the "Nationalists" that they would not concur in particular agreements pending with Peking, put an end to negotiations with the North which might seriously have prejudiced foreign rights in China had they led to documentary understandings. Such a statement from Canton in the Spring of 1926, helped greatly to put an end to futile prolongation of the moribund Tariff Conference, which was a distinct blessing. There were both Governments and individual delegates who would' not believe that all hope of constructive work was dead until Canton, with forceful finality, announced that the "Nationalist Government. would recognize the validity of no agreement reached with the Fengtien administration in Peking. This year, it will be remembered, the protest of the Hankow Government and the threat to seize the administration of the Customs in all "Nationalist" territory, made it impossible for Sir Francis Aglen to ace to Peking's demand that the Customs collect the Washington surtaxes, There are, even apart from Canton under its new radical masters, large areas of China which are sufficiently independent of both Nanking and Peking to announce that they too must be consulted and concur in all treaties and agreements before they are valid and binding, and we heartily wish they would do s0. We are menaced by nothing in this country so much as the whims of our Home Governments inspired, as they so often are, by misunderstanding of our problems or by waves of imis-guided public opinion, Tf we could feel that the Chinese themselves had created a situa-

(Continued on Page 354.)

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account