The Archive · 1927

A Ridiculous Demand

"The Chinese need educational institutions sadly. Well over 90 per! cent, of the copie are illiterate. An attempt vas made by the Goverment, after the Republic was pro-damied, to provide schools, but although there have been paper programmes and some local successes, there has been no consistency or! permanence, and at present the Government schools are generally closed for lack of funds. 'There is nothing to compare with the schools and colleges which the Missions have slowly and Inboriously built up! with an effort extending over halt' a century. Yet we are asked to hand these over to the Chinese before they have proved themselves; capable of establishing and managing any stable system of their own, The "independence" of churches, schools and hospitals which" the students have vociferously demanded has nothing in it of a constructive nature. We have witnessed the s0- called "Nationalist" movement destroy mission institutions one after the other, but there is no instance of their building up anything which can take their place, "There is no question but that this movement is anti-foreign and anti Christian, How else can the attacks on hospitals be explained? Here are institutions which have done nothing but good to the Chinese and which they are incapable of replacing. In most of the cities they have been the only places where the people could obtain medical aid. There are a few personally ran hospitals which have had a more or Jess temporary existence managed by' Chinese doctors, but nothing on large scale or which is conducted purely as charitable work.

Americans Not Wanted plain enough that the Government does not] efforts have been made, and are continuing, to make life impossible for ne in China, Misefon properties have been taken over, looted, ana] defiled in every possible way, or even burned as was done at Nanking. This is not the work of irresponible outlaws, but a deliberate and systematic practice with an unmistakable objective. You can follow the process wherever the Nationalist movement has reached; in Kuang. two, up through Kiangsi, in Hunan and down the Yangtze, "There has been a persistent propaganda in the United States to resent the facts in a different light jand it is unfortunate that s0 many well meaning and—responsible Americans have been _misinformed and misled by this propaganda.

"In some Missions the Chinese Christians have fallen into this movement and have demanded that Mission institutions should be hi fed over to them, that they should have the entire' management and complete control of the funds, but!

the same time they beg inconsistently that the contributions. for the support of the work should still be furnished by the Missionary Boards in the United States.

"Now one Important thing to keep) in mind is that we could do no greater harm to the Christian com-'China than to provide vast amount of property which they had little or nothing to do with paying for. Audits are things they know little about. The sense of trusteeship is very weak and fands are apt to be borrowed for purposes for which they were never intended. Tt is not that there are not many honest and honourable Chinese. It is quite possible to create 2 board of such 1en and turn over property to them, t the difficulty would be for them to retain control. The disposition of the better class Chinese is to iced or step aside in the face of and_ opposi and. the contposi n of such boards would shortly be altered by intriguers who, would soo be in control and use the institution for their own ends.

"In our own Mission we intend for this reason to take no risks with St. John's University but will mai tain control or keep the doors closed till we can open them under a just Government and reasonable educational regulations. On the point of trusteeship it is worth attention that up to the present the laws and the practice ut the Chinese Com we sce them in action give no sufficient guarantee that our institutions "and funds would protected so that the ends for which they were established could be permanently secured.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account