The Archive · 1931

Order in Shanghai

Nov. 27.

The Shanghai Municipal Council is appealing against the decision of the District Court in the case of the four men accused of robbery but found guilty of forcible interference. with the rights of others and awarded purely nominal sentences. The appeal is not likely to be heard for several weeks. In the meantime the situation likely to be created by thi may be serian: Tt is impossible therefore to regard the matter' jas sub judice in the ordinary acceptance of that term.

The facts in the case are not in pute. The four pickets, working under the direction of the Anti-'Japanese Association, forcibly removed under threats of violence goods to the value of $1,760 from the shop of a Chinese trader in Ningpo Road. This was done in spite of the fact that the goods were mot of Japanese origin. Moreover the shopkeeper offered to give up a sample for special investigation and if it were found to be Japanese he was ready to surrender the whole stock. The pickets—their number was ingenuously explained by one of their own witnesses in Court as being determined by the necessity to prevent bribery—took no notice of this sporting off They carried off the goods in truck. The goods were not returned and it is noteworthy that the Court, although finding the accused technically guilty, made no order for their return to the rightful owner. It should be: added that the Judge explained—and, therefore, admitted—the lightness of the sentence by serting that the accused were actuated by patriotic motly The same excuse of patriotism st would no doubt. be brought forward to condone the action of the latest band of students who cheated the Government's Railway administration out of its dues and smashed up railway property, fa order to proceed Nanking for a, protest against sinment's foreign policy.

it explains the failure to punish ary of the miscreants who "beat up" Dr. C. T. Wang) and were directly responsible for his retirement into private life, after having more successfully championed China's cause with Foreign Powers than any of recent incumbents of his office. That, however, is not the most serious aspect of this judgment, Tt confronts the Shanghai Municipal Council with a definite example of the difficulty which it is likely to experience in enforcing law and order in the Settlement, when the Chinese Courts cannot be relied upon to administer the law of the land, No one can view the present ' position here with. Jequanimity. At any moment the Council may find itself presented with a crisis of the first magnitude, Any development which weakens its powers of appropria late executive action for the prevention of trouble has, therefore, all the elements of menacing danger. This journal has endeavoured persistently to impress on the Chinese Government the extreme undesirability of a tacit encouragement of these boycott activities. They! present to the Japanese an oj portunity of which decisive use might be made were not the Council exercising its powers of persuasion, side by side with incessant executive vigilance, to avert the precipitation of a crisis, Then, when China is engaging the sympathies: of the League, it is exceedingly bad policy—to put the argument on no higher ground—to incur risks which are inevitably latent in the boycott plan.

It is suggested that the Judge under the censure of ang pu for daring even to find the accused men guilty fat all. The District Court, it should be remembered, is an'institution still on its trial. has come into existence as the outcome of a desire to assist in the development in China of that independent administration of justice on which, in the last resort, all good government rests. Buttressed by the special conditions obtaining in Shanghai it was expected to be able to shake off the trammels of executive interference and susceptibility to political prejudice with more certainty of success than Chinese courts elsewhere. If the record of the last few months is any guide, so far from the Court besee ble to fall under the ing able to set an example

[same malign influences as have done disservice to the reputation of China in other parts of the country. It is likely to sap the authority of the very institution from which it could be thought to derive the incentive to independent dispensation of just ice, The Shanghai Municipal Council cannot afford to permit this to happen. The circumstances of the present difficulties render impossible an adherence a. policy of unchecked complaisance. An appeal has been lodged in this case. It seems. that the Council will have to more. As a start it might make strong representation for the return to the shopkeeper of the goods illegally withheld. It should also take into urgent con sideration the possibility of instituting stricter preventive measures against the activities of the boycotters within its jurisdiction, It has. the right. and the power effectively to do this, It must, in the interests of the Chinese'as well as of the foreign residents, do all that it can to make action from other quarters unnecessary and un-Justifiable.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account