The Archive · 1927

OUR MUNICIPALITY

Smanicnat: 178 Montctratiry aNp ChINESE-"By "A. at., Kotenev. Shanghai, "Norih-China Dally News @ Herald" Ta, 1927. Price $15.09 (alex).

This timely work,. which is companion volume to "Shanghai Its Mixed Court and Council" by the same author, deals with modern problems facing the Shanghai Municipal Council and its relations with the ever increasing Chinese population, especially in regard to the administrations of justice and municipal by-laws, In Part T the history of the Council and the Mixed Court is dealt with in detail together with the events leading up to the inauguration of the pre~ sent Provisional Court. The pro-_ lem of child Inbour, Shanghai and China's polities, and Chinese representation are'all dealt with, the Author being, careful togive his authorities throughout and, where necessary, documentary evidence in the way of letters and text of findings and rulings 'There could have been no more appropriate time for the apppearance of this book than the sunt, for the recent action of the new' Chinese Nationalist Govern iment in attempting to impose a two sronths! vent tox upon the Chinese Tiving within the Settlement, and the tieatened refusal of the Chinese to phy the 2 per cent. increase in the satnicipal rates recently decided upon by the Connell come as challenge to the whole status of the Council, and, indeed, to the pre~ sence of the foreigner in Shang-hah, Tt behoves everybody—interested—and who living in Shanghai is not interested?—to know the principles and regulations upon Which this community is governo? and how those principles and regulations came about. Mr. ency's book supplies just thi formation. It does more: it -sub-jests he facts of past history ant "the problems of to-day to a search-criticism which al throws "The Ming Sung Umbrella Case,"

shows very clearly the fun dame tal cause of all the difficult arising over the attempt to ad: minister justice in regard to the Chinese in the Settlement, He} points out that the trouble lies in the impossibility of reconciling the psychology of the Chinese with that of the foreigner. "All the ideas ments of the foreigners la connexion with the political amt social issues in dispute are based on legal considerations and lay, fon international treaties and strict les of jurisprud~ ence. This sometimes painful process arouses in the eyes of the Chinese only astonishment ant mistrust. In their views, treaties and precedents are no mere than prejudices, which stand in the way of what they think, rightly or wrongly, to be just and fair. They cannot understand the attitude of the foreigners and "lin heir respect of law. question brought this out very clearly, Tt had -to with the ques tion of the liability of partners 4 Chineve firm which failed. The Chinese submitted that it was the prevailing custom in China that a partner ina firm was only responsible, in the event of failure, to the extent of the money he had put.

and that, since there was 0 Taw the ease, The foreign ied that since there ax no Chinese law covering. the ease the common to other countries should apply, namely that any one member of partnership should be liable for the debts of the whole partnership. In the end the Chinese judge youred the Chinese view a the foreign one the foreign. view; but it was perfectly obvious that neither of the contending parties could see the other's viewpoint, and, as already stated, the cai serves well as an example of the difficulty of harmon' and Chinese ideas vernment and the of justice..

Part I of the volume deals with the opium. problem in Shang! it makes very interesting reading. Tt is impossible to go in detail here into the question of opium suppress jon by the Municipal Council, as it!

'a large and involved one, but it} muy be worth while to emphasize jew of the Council in this con~ nexion during the years when' stocks of Indian opium were being digsipated, namely, that the process of opium suppression must necessarily be a gradual one keeping pace with the diminishing stocks of opium in Shanghai, if dislocation of financial} arvengements of both foreign and Chinese residents, merchants anil bankers and grave administrative] complications were to be avoided. There were those who opposed this} view and who ®emanded the mediate drastic suppression of opium smoking in the Settlement} regardless of consequences. For the information of these reformers may be pointed out that one of the things that the Council feared in the suppression of opium in the 'Settlement has come about, namely' that the trade instead of being] under control as it was in the days fof licenses has been driven under yround into illegal channels, and) is now far greater and more tucretive than ever it was. It is now] laponly connived at and even abetted by the Chinese military, navel) and civil authorities, to whom "grivggled" opium is an enormous} source of revenue, In fact, it Jjuat this enormous revenue derived from opium that has made Shanghai the prize of every military adventurer and has involved—this ogion in each of the. several wars! that have taken place in China in the last few years. The net result} of Great Britain's agreement with} China to abolish her big trade in Indian opium on condition that the Chirese Government would suppress opium growing in China, has been' to sareifice a handsome revenue herself and to make opium so high priced in China that the Chinese, militarists, derive a huge revenue teach year' from "squeeze" imposed upon illicit opium smuggled into Shanghai and up and down the country by a ring of so) powerful as even to be able to dicta fate the policy of those militarists. Opium smoking and the use of Jeven more deleterious narcotics far more rampant in China to-day] than ever it was before the opium Hveform movement was started, and, what is worse, the profits derived from it form one of the chief in-Jeentives to the everlasting military Joverations of the various war lords in the country. The xmugeled onium trade, of which Shanghai is the centre, is worth at least million taels a month to any Tord who can hold Shanghai, while jup and down the whole length of China a proportionate revenue derived from the traffic in opium. The Shanghai Municipal—Counei had perforce to do its best to suppress opium smoking in the Settlement, since this was the policy of the British and Chinese Governments, but the number of prosecu tions, amounting in 1925 to 3,264] Jan increasing rapidly, against persons on charges connected with opium bears eloquent testimony the great increase instead of de-Jcrease of the opium trade. It is nut too much to say, in the light fof subsequent events, that it would have been far wiser never to have attempted the abolition of opium in China, but to have recognized and controlled it by licensing and to have allowed it to die a natural Jdeath as the people became educated away from its use. We strongly recommend the reading of _this part of Mr. Kotenev's book t9 all who Jare in any way interested in the suppression of opium. It will prove jan eye-opener to them.

Burt IIT of the book is devoted to the reproduction of _various edicts, regulations, and laws now] in force in that part of China in which Shanghai lies, such, for stance, ils the Provisional Constitution' of the Republic of Narking, 1912, Regulations Govern: ing Military Courts-Martial, 1915- 1921, the Revised Law of Nation~ ality, 1914, and so on, all of which itis' highly useful to "have in such accessible form. These help to make the book a most valuable reference "work. ° The book is written in a simple and easy style and we

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account