The Archive · 1928

THREE, COURTS OF JUSTICE

Sermon Preached in Union Church, Shanghai on Sunday Morning, March 18, 1928, by the Rev. E. F, Horst-Smith a very small thing that I should be judged of you—I judo not mine.own eel-—He that judge th me ts the Lard." Gor. 1V: v. 8 and 4.

"do, not wish to. tire you with Frequent references to the convorsial spirit with which the arch at Corinth was cursed, and hall. only. refer to it now as a ring point, but you will recall t there were four parties in that arch and that three of them were tile to Paul and made invidious ipagisons between him and other sisting leaders. There is, how-x, nothing petty in the. reply of ai, He does not try to make a ul' debating point, He deals lithe subject in a large-minded clarifies the issue and os a real contribution to our right by telling his readers that re are three courts of just with its own functions an ers. Let us then dismiss from thoughts the specific instance of cliques at Corinth and think for ttle while of these three courts. may describe them ay the lower rt, the higher court and the rome court, -—There is first of all the Lower it, which has reference ment, by other people. Paul tes:——"Tt is a small thing that ould be judged of you or of Judgment" "The specific ican that Paul had in mind was bably the opinion of only a fe however, made enough nek mistaken for a larger number 1 they really were. When peo-purport to represent others, it atten a fair question to as many are there of your tat proportion of the whole group you represent? Are the many int people whose opinions are exprenged. of your way of king?" Even when we have a urine wish to be guided by the tion of others, we must not be tily. rushed by' those who speak 3 for the per sort who speaks frat 7'ge.a0 fond. of spanking that ne hot let any chance pass. He therefore, speak, whether anything to say or not and he rot even properly represent his 1 mature thought, far less any-also's, The Sense of Proportion Coreover, the critical people Paut in mind were by no means free Bias. They were partisans partisans always lack a sani portion, Consciously oF. uncon ussly, they select their facts and very much more than they udo. By their, disproportionate shagis_on one set of facts, to exclusion of all others, they indeed, perform a useful ction in a community, but wise are well advised not to be uly influenced by them, for there always another side,' probably ay other sides, and the leader alters his policy to please any clique, by that very act cliques. These con-how the limitations and erections of what we have call-the lower court of justice, we should not ignore its uses, 1 ig a critical animal, He has 1 endowed with the critical alty and all natural endowments intended for use. You cannot him to go through life with eyes shut. He is bound to hold sort of opinion on men and for:

You cannot rule out of one man by another, it would be a lose to the man the object of criticism if you Did not Robert Burns suggest men' should pray for the gift, teeing, themselves as others see ut. That means placing a fair-sigh value on the judgment of its, Now, the opinion of others "befavourable or unfavourable; vary from carping criticism one hand to fulsome praise the, other. Perhaps. its most tified expression is found in we call public. opinion, which urined by the gradual sifting of vidual opinions and which re-3 in the widespread acceptance a general body of ideas, and opinion, thug formed, is very, erful. Tt is more powerful than lation, because. legislation, is helpless. without it, and inevitable it. It was public opinion that ided slavery, and the reason that'

ar is not yet outlawed is not through lack of legislation, but because public opinion has not quite reached that stage, No one can defy the opinion of others, as ex-amplified in public opinion, with impunity, but the judgment of others, whether it is favourable or not, whether it is expressed in the most humiliating and degrading form of scandal, or in the most dignified form of public opinion, is imperfect. It has its uses, but it ig. the lower court, and, regarding it, Paul writes:—"Tt is a small thing that I should be judged of you,"

The Higher Court 2—Then there is, secondly, the higher court, namely, self-judgment, He writes:—"T fudge not mine own self." That is a negative statement, it is true, but it implies a positive, Tt implies that there is this second tribunal at which a man may be judged by himself. Tt is an interesting. problem as to hav that can bbe don ies a kind of dualism. that there are two personalities in the one man—one the bench as magistrate, the other is in the dock as prisoner; one is the accuser, the other the accused. "I judge myself*—one part of me is subject, the other is object, Judgment of that kind is certain to involve problems of ite own, but there is this to be said for it—self-judgment is better informed than judgment by others. A' man kndwa all kinds of things about himself that are not known by any other person. For that reason, many Aman may pass muster before the court constituted by his fellows who would have mo chance whatayor against the bar of his own Over against that fuller knowledge we have to put something that often more than counteracts it, namely, the more sympathetic na-fire of self-judgment. When we ourselves perform the duties of Judge a8 well as accept the position prisoner we ato likely to make very liberal allowances, Take the same fault in others, how base it is, how deserving of censure, how open it is to the sternest denuncintion, In ourselves, how different it seems, how many extenuating circumstances can be found, AS you know, that is one of nature's face-saving contri We show our indignation against our faults not by criticizing them in ourselves, where they really cause the trouble, but by condemning them in others. When we have heard one person denouncing another as selfish, autocratic, arbitrary, vain, deceitful, dishonest, we have often noticed that these are the very blemishes that mark the accuser himself. He fs fighting the thing that ought to be fought, but he is fighting it in the wrong person. Thus, many. elf-judgments are too lenient, and, although we know regarding ourselves far more that is unworthy than do our sternest critics, yet we make allowances that more than counter-balance our fuller knowledge. That consideration. might Tend. us to. question whether. the court of self-judgment is indeed the igher court.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account