The Archive · 1927

The Shanghai Problem

July 19, A correspondent of the "Manchester Guardian," has, according to an article published else-Hwhere in our columns, continued seek for British errors in the handling of the Shanghai problem. Again, there is the proposal to find a solution of the: differences of opinion between the Shanghai Municipal Council land a body which calls itself the Chinese Ratepayers' Association' by that curious compromise of taking the Interdational Settle-Iment.away from the-Council and withdrawing it from China by making it a free city after the fashion of Danzig, which is governed under the general sup-of the Nations.

Such proposals as [this one usually emanate from a definitely knowh Chinese poli {tical quarter and are always re-|}, jected' by all responsible Chinese a breach of China's sover-eighty and by most responsible foreigners as further complic ing dri already to complex political problem.

Were the Foreign Settlement the whole of Shanghai, the Jquestion of its relationship China might be simplified, for that relationship involves the question of expansion. This is the only consideration—which'

fies thinking about the} "neutralization" of the Shanghai jara, The fifth port of the Hworld must expand and there is plenty of room for such expansion, but curiously enough, that} expansion seems to take place almost entirely within the narrow bounds of the Foreign [Settlement. The lower end of ithe French Concession has been Imade attractive to commerce and business but they have not gone there, preferring the more costly premises within the confines of the Settlement. Dr. V. K, Ting evolved a reasonable plan of at-acting commerce and industry to the northern part of his territory—in a region between Kiangwan and Woosung, but] nothing canie of that. Chapel jand Nantao as they are now jeonstituted are not likely to be able to assimilate surplus enterprises from the International [Settlement. Yet, it is absurd for a city to expand upward towards the sky when there is much cheap ground on its very boundaries. The argument In favour of "neutralization and amalgamation of political entity ies" can be supported from this one standpoint alone. Beyond that, it is at every point unsound.

The difference of opinion between the Chinese and the foreigners with regard to the Forjeign Settlement is so fundament. al thai it is difficult to find a makeshift compromise. TT! Chinese say that the land theirs and that even if their an-stars gave it to the foreigner jas a dwelling place and their commerce, they can at any, time and in any way they decide, take it back or modify the foreigner's tenure. They do} not, therefore, request represent. ation on the Council, nor are they willing even to discuss the! foreign view. They demand. now not an equal voice but a superior control after the tion of the settlement of the|® Hankow Concession in accord-lance with the Chen-O'Malley agreement.

The foreigners on the other hand, claim that they were given the Settlement because they were unwanted in Chinese te ritory. They were thrust upon swamp gnd told to: live there las they pleased. They spent 50 years or more turning that swamp into a wonderful city. It was clearly defined as thei place to live, their ghetto, as it were. No one interfered with them. The Chinese officials di not assist them to build this wonderful city. The Chinese who came into it, came as re~ fugees from the oppression of, their own officials, or because! their lives and property were] unsafe during civil commotions, or because they preferred its} order and cleanliness and general safety to the-chaos where they came-from. In no instances were they invited to come or asked to stay. Yet, it is admitted that their coming ha: increased the wealth of the, place, has added to land values and has brought about such' economic results as are naval with increased: population and increased purchasing power.

These two points of view are irreconcilable in logic anti fact. All measures taken to reconcile them have ended in failure. The only political possibilities in the situation are the maintenance of ithe status quo or a cHange of] contractual relationships by the negotiation of a new treaty [between China aid the Powers concerned with regard to Skangthai. A temporary expedient may be worked out with a_ view towards giving the Chinese residents a voice in the manage-Iment of the Foreign Settlement, that during this transitional period in China's affairs when there is no responsible Government with which the Powers can negotiate a treaty, the Chinese residents of the Settlement, those who pay rates and have inter-lests here, may make themsel heard ina manner more digni fie than the holding of meetings lby the youth of Chapei and Nantao at the West Gate Recreation Grounds. But the effort! lof the Council to find such al voice has proved futile, because Chinese politicians have sought to utilize this proposal as a means for winning a diplomatic victory -on the noise of which! they could' climb into an oficial position in China, Since thet [Chinese politicians have been lusing the "Shanghai Question"

a means of - boosting themselves individually, the Council! has naturally grown more wary in its negotiations, for the Foreign Settlement must be kept! lout of China's internecine polit-fes at any cost.

Now, the "Manchester Guardian" ' and other—so-called liberal-minded organs seem to believe that the foreigners in Shanghai enjoy quarrels with their Chinese neighbours and delight in having their busine: spoiled by irritating politi They do not seem to grasp the fact that the one thing the fo eigners crave is peace and an opportunity to resume the friendly commercial relations for which they came to this country. Such proposals then, as include further invasions of China's! territory except under the dirlest necessity of protecting life! and property, lead to nothing but invitation' and bad feeling. Were some "die-hard" organ of opinion to: suggest taking a rich land populous area of China and handing it over to the League of Nations, it would be regarded lby the Chinese as imperialistic, but the "Manchester Guardian" thas a reputation for liberalism! and, therefore, the sting in the proposal is delightfully camouaged. It is there, however and we who live in Shanghai, would soon enough know its sence by a steady agitation against us were such a proposall to find official sanction. As for} ithe Chinese who favour neutral one sometimes wonders whether their suggestions in this direction are not made with! the deliberate purpose of making] Imore trouble in the Settlement, iso that they might fish more easily in our troubled waters,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account