Peking, Apr. 4.
The settlement made by Mr. MacMurray, the Amesican Minister, with. Nanking is the sole topic in diplomatic circles to-day, in which it does not escape criticism, The most charitable verdict that Mr. MacMurray made the very best of a bad job under orders from Washington inspired by the British effort. Yet it is unanimously agreed that the American expression deploring the need for the barrage and mention of the treaties should not have been admitted in conn: tion with the outrage, since if obviously introduced, wit intent, by the Chinese to be mi construed as a face-saving quid pro 'The local Chinese press already' proves what an error ithas been by headlines annourteing an apology for the gunboat barrage and a promise of treaty revision as exchanges for the settlement, Diplomats appreciative of Mr. MacMurray's astute wording, point, in particular to his obvious effort to avoid mention of the Nanking Government, so that the latter remains unrecognized. The nearest approach in the text is "the Nanking Authorities."
Despite approval of these verbal tactics, the local diplomatic world generally deplores the settlement ug to provide for the one vital essential, namely, such preven tive punishment of responsible military commanders as might have effectually discouraged any repetition. The punitive clause in the [completely nullifying the effect of the skilful verbal fencing so far as
opposed to ignorant bureaux' and public opinion abroad, French Minister to Stay on An order has been received by the French Minister, the Comte de Martel, to delay Home.' This is naturall ed in all Chinese yamens to mean that the French Minister has been instructed to emulate Mr. Mac-Murray in the Nanking settlement before returning.
Treaty Revision Washington, Apr. 2.
Coincident with an announcement by the State Department that the settlement of the Nanking incident reached between the American Minister to China and the Nationalist Foreign Minister is satisfactory to the United States Govern ment, the Secretary of State Mr. Frank B, Kellogg has issued a statement renewing the pledge he made in January, 1927, that the United States is willing to open negotiations for new treaties to replace the so-called unequal treat ies whenever a delegation fairly representative of all China requests such action—Reuter,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.