The Archive · 1928

Day Kimball

He was followed shortly after by Flag Captain K. G, B. Dewar, Then Rear-Admival B, St G. Collard, arrived, an impressive figure with a row of decorations, and mounted the gangway of the Eagle, at the foot of which photographers were very busy.

Captain F, Burges Watson presided at the Court Martial, which consisted of eight captai The proceedings opened with the Deputy Judge-Advocate, Captain LIH, S. Measham, reading the wa rant convening the, Court and thei the charges.

Commander Daniel pleaded "Not The seats open to the public were occupied chiefly by officers in- uniform. No women were present.

The Deputy Judge-Advocate quoted from the letter to Captain Dewar connection with which Commander Daniel is charged, and vhich describes the circumstances of Rear-Admiral Collard's landing at Malta from the Royal Oak.

The Commander's Letter The letter referred to a "great commotion on. the quarter deck owing to the Admiral's anger." Tt alleged that. Rear-Admiral. Collard Geclared that he waa "fed. up_ with the ship." Commander Daniel, in this letter, expressed. the opinion that the morale of the ship. had suffered und. discipline had" been endangered by the incidents. Ha fide, "Ail. the officers. are deeply resentful of the humiliation to which He added that Commander Danis! on the 10th March assentbled the officers of the Royal Oak in the ward-room and informed them of the court of inquiry to be held. He read to the wardroom a letter which he said Captain Dewar had written regarding Admiral Collard's conduct and asked who could give evidence to substantiate the charges in that. letter, He then read his own letter to Admiral Collard, Giving evidence, Commander Daniel said that he took ashore the letter from himself which aecompanied the letter from Captain Dewar and handed them to Admiral Collard, Cross-examined Commander Daniel id he had read his letter carefully. He agreed that it was a serious matter concerning him personally.

The Deputy Judge Advocate allowed a question asked by Mr. Day Kimball on the grownd that Admiral Collard's conduct was irre ovant to the charges against Commander Daniel.

Mr. Day Kimball said that the Court-martial had been granted at the request of Commander Daniel and it whole purpose would be defeated if such questions were disallowed.

Vhe Court decided Admiral Col-Inrd's conduct was irrelevant but admissible, The Alleged Language The Deputy Judge-Advocate read Captain Dewar's letter in which he expressed extreme reluctance to criticize a superior, but felt it his duty when "discipline was being undermined, He referred to a remark made by Admiral Collard regarding the ship's band to the effect that he Wid never heard such a aster in the most opprobrious The letter complained that Admiral Collard remarked that the Oak was not fit to be an V's flag-ship. He was treated their ship_and captain have been subjected," declaring that "apologies would serve no. useful purpose." The letter concluded by anying that Commander Daniel himself had not suffered but he considered it would be cowardice not to report the matter.

The reading by the prosecution fof Commander Daniel's letter Captain Dewar, which is the ba the charges, shows that whea Admiral Collard required his barge to leave the Royal Oak on March 5 Commander Daniel ordered the starboard" accomodation-ladder to be prepared after inquiring and ascertaining that there was no choice of sides owing to the voughnees of the sea. Commander Daniel was summoned to Admiral Collard's presence and found Lecause the port aecomoda der was not ready. Admiral Collard der Daniel t> see The disew: tariation of the Admiral was effected without damage. Commander Daniel subsequently learned that Adm Collard had told Captain Dewar, a rode voice and in th fof seamen, that he was the ship." Commander I his letter, dwelt on the serious harm vf sach incidents, adding that a previous occasion great pains had Leen necessary to restore respect for the Admiral, Commander Daniel felt that the Admiral's wie fairness and insult before nearly 100 officers and men on the March 5 had a serious effect on disciple and morale. Commander Danie! said that an assurance was urgent neceseitey that discipline must not be undermined in this way.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account