The Archive · 1927

PHILIPS vy. THE CHINA THEATRES, LTD

Suit was begun on Tuesday in H. M, Supreme Court before Judge Peter' Grain by Mr. F. Philips against the China 'Theatres, Ld., for $1,264, alleged to be due plaintiff in lieu of three months' notice of dismissal from his place as manager of the Carlton Theatre, and partly' for quarters between March 16 and; April 30, Mr. A. M. Preston represented plaintiff, while Mr, Tycho} Wing acted for defendant company.

In his opening remarks Mr, Preston drew attention to plaintiff's long service with the company and its predecessor (in all 12 years and eight months) and to the fact that defendants had given notice of missal on September 3, 1926, which they later waived, and that on January 81, 1927 another one month's notice had been given. His client refused to necept the legality of the notice and about' May 1 in-fructed him to file suit, Most of the odso consisted in the introduction of correspondence be tween plaintiff? and defendant com-Dany. In giving evidence Mr. Philips said that he had signed two contracts whilst working first, for Mr. Bari and later for the China Theatres, Ld. The third contract had not been signed, but he considered as working under its terms, and as he said, the company had more or less considered the contract binding in their correspondence.

witness considered he had a verbal cement in the terms of the pro: Posed contract. Although the company had sent him two signed contracts, which he was to sign and return one to them, he had not done 40, He had objected to a clause which stipulated that he could not within two years of his severing relations with the company,—asfoclate himself with another theatre] in Shanghai.

This clause, continued witness, was to be discussed upon the ing director's arrival in Shanghai but. he added, he was so busy preparing for Home leave, that he witness), had no opportunity for iseussion.

Referring to the contract, witness! anid that the company had paid hin the increased salary in June 1926 as the contract stipulated, and ed to the Court the letter referring] to the cheque, 'The letter of September 93, which gave him a month's notice, stated that duo to an economizing' policy fon the part of the company, his services would not be required, but that they would give him a letter of reference. To this he replied that ho had a contract, and that he wanted it carried out and demanded compensation for vacating quarters. From their reply of September 1 Velioved that he possessed contract, a8 the letter stated thal the quarters were merely a conces~ ion. Several other letters were changed and on October 16, 1926: he received a communication suggesting friendly arrangement. After that he heard nothing until. the second notice of dismissal on Tanuary 13, 1927, On February 1, he replied that he had always considered the financial standing of the company and pointed out that during hard times in Peking he had accepted a 10 per on, reduction in salary. To Mr. Proston—I was always willing to] meet them and accept a reduction! in salary.

In his letter of February 22 he said that no doubt he from them regarding pa To Mr. Preston he said that Bari had promised passage and that. Mr. Haslund, secretary of the company, had confirmed this. arrangement, On February 26, Mr. Lee Kan wrote him saying that they were not legally bound to purchase his Passage, and that as he had been engaged locally there was no moral onus"on the company either.

'On March 18, witness demanded three months! salary and compensation; for: quarters,. and: om April 23 wrote, desiring an' answer to his former letter.

'On May 6, Mr, Preston, accords ing to witness wrote them demanding_two months' salary (one havin Replying to Mr. Preston witness said that Mr. Haslund had paid him personally the last month's salary jon. February 28. This was. most fenusual. Witness complained state ting that he demanded three months" notice.

Judge Grain—Was it given you?

Continuing plaintiff said that he telephoned Mir. L. R. Andrews, president of the company, who informed him that nothing could be done.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account