Inesday his Honour Judge Peter Grain gave judgment for the plaintiff in the sums of Tis, 2,300, Tls. 115, and $318.13 in the case in which Miss Marie Palkin swed the China General Omnibus Ca, Ld. for damages in respect of injuries sustained in a motor bus accident on April 2 last, Mr. J. E. Badeley appeared for the plaintiff and the defendant company was represented by Mr. R, F. C, Master.
The full judgment is as follows:
In every case of this type there always great discrepancy between the evidence of the two parties concerned and it is only by a.careful analysis of the whole evidence that ne is enabled to arrive at the exact facts and even then it often happens that one is enabled only to arrive Jat the probable exact facts. It is alleged by the plaintiff Marie Palkin, a Rassian subject, that on April 2, 1927 she was about to get into an omnibus belonging to the defendants the China General Omnibus Ca., La.
That the omnibus had halted opposite the shop of Hall & Holtz jin the Nanking Read and she was fakout to get in, the gates being open, ge hen the omnibus started. [That the omnibus again stopped and she again attempted to get in, when the omnibus again started, she had lonly"got one foot on the step and had caught hold of the rail. Her foot slipped as the omnibus started ind she wus dragged a considerable distance and suffered injury. defendants: plead. that, the accident fund the injury caused to the plaintiff was due to the plaintiff's negligfence in wrongfully attempting to board an omnibus when in motion, and that if there was any negligence} fon the part of the defendant's servants the plaintiff contributed to by hee own negligence and they wre not liable.
The evidence of Marie Palkin is that she was waiting at Hall & Holtz Road for an oronibus, She waited some minutes and there met a Mr. Vrublesky the manager fof the Record Beauty Parlor where she worked. 'The omnibus came up land stopped at Hall & Holts, about the first window coming from the Bund. They waited for some passengers to get out, there were not many passengers, as it was an omnibus going West' at about 8.30
Vrublevsky then stood aside to} allow her to pass and get into the omnibus first, he had hold of the band rail and' one foot on step when the omnibus started without warning. Vrublevsky then sprang on to the ste and the inspector who was standing by the bell on the platform at the rear of the tram, seeing that she the plaintitt was Toft behind rang the bell and stopped the omnibus. It stopped this time just by the last window of Hall Holtz "shop, namely at corner of hold of the rail. the gates being still open, and had just got her foot] on the lower step, when the omnibus} again started forward, her foot slipped, she held on to the rail, and] Vrublevsky caught her by the arm, but she was dragged some distance and at last had to release her hold and she fell in the roadway.
She states that her foot slipped almost immediately. Mr, Vrublevsky ives the same evidence. He states that the inspector was on the platform at the rear of the tram by the bell throughout the occurrence but! that the conductor went inside to collect fares after the first stop and was inside when the accident happened.
He states that the gates were open al the tine, but when he was getting the, first. stop, the conductor: came forward to shut them, but] when he got on as the omnibus bogan to move off the conductor left. the gates and went inside the omnibus, He says that the first time it started it did not start fast, but the second time it started it seemed to. start faster, about 5 or:6 miles-an hour.
The evidence called on behalf the defendant company differs materially from the statements of the plaintiff and her witnesses.
The Chinese inspector and conductor who were on the tram and a cess pacmnetes_ (eho "eas sabed give evidence ey Yung-kee, witnesses called on behalf of the defendants, The story they tell is that Marie Palkin and Vrublevaky were not waiting at Hall & Holtz when the omnibus stopped. That the omnibus started and "had crossed _the Szechuan Road when the man and woman ran after it, that the man jumped on opposite Watson's Chemists shop, and that the woman tried to jump on almost immediately} after the man. 'That as soon as the lady slipped the bell was rung' and the omnibus stopped opposite Laz-Jams optician's shop. The conductor says he saw them both running after the omnibus, that this is obviously imagination on the part of the conductor is evident as all the witnesses including the Chinese passenger and the inspector himself say he was inside collecting fares.
The Chinese passenger says the Jconductor was not there when the lady got her foot on the step. The Chinese passenger, who was by the inspector to give evidence does support the story of the spector in the main, but incidently a some way corroborate the} plaintiff's story. He says they running to catch the omnibus and makes the accident happen on the other side of Szechuan Road, namely} between the Tobacco shop and the Lace shop, which is someway passed Watson's,' the chemists. But also says that the first stoyi of the omnibus was about 10 yards from the corner which considering the Length of the omnibus would bring the gate way of the omnibus. to about the place at Hall & Holtz where the plaintiff says the first stop took place. He also says that] when the woman got her foot on the step the "Inspector rang his bell but the omnibus was still in motion as soon as the woman slipped her foot he rang again and the omnibus} stopped: "almost immediately He says the gates remained about two-thirds open all the time, and] that the omnibus "started slowly} but by, Szechuan Road it was going raster.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.