The Archive · 1928

F. J. Schuhl

Payment had been demanded, said the plaintiffs, in the original' petition which was heard by the Commissioner, Mr. Nelson P. Lurton,, Fast year, and the defendant had refused to pay. A counter claim had been entered.

Failing the first count the plain. tiff sought judgment on a second count—that of Tis, 449.15, and $146.60, with costs.

Mr, Franklin stated that the case had been "about half before Mr. Lurton," and it would save considerable time if he and Mr. Schuht were permitted to ask for a recess for ten minutes or so, in order that 'a number of the counts might be eliminated. The Commissioner: granted the recess, and during the recess the opposition lawyers eliminated several points of disagreement.

The first witness called was one Bacon W. Yau, chief clerk in the Shanghai Horse Bazaar and Motor Cou, Ltd.

The Commissioner asked if any reply had been received to the counter claim of the defendant, and Mr. Schuhl (for the defendant) stated that there was no reason according to a recent judgment why the defendant should reply to 'a counter claim.

Mr. Schuh! questioned witness with regard to his method of bookkeeping, and atked him whether entries inthe books were made from chits.—Witness said all entries were made from chits—but he seemed rather confused, and afterwards said that entries were sometimes made without"ehits, Inter saying that sometimes entries were from the book which was kept in the godown.

Mr. Franklin interjected that enjes could be made without chits "T can go to garages," he said "without signing "Then you must have exceptionally good credit" rejoined Mr. Schuhl, several items in the account for which no chits could be produced, and he admitted that he could not produce the hits, for no chits were Signed. Mr. Schuhl thereupon contended that the books could not be taken as evidence, for they were not original entries.

The Commissioner told Mr, Franklin: that it was a question of Taw whether they could get the books of. the plaintiffs admissible as evidence, and Mr. Schuhl said he would challenge every item in the books which was not supported by a chit.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account