The Archive · 1922

The Question of Publicity

Mar. 21.

Frost time to time the editor of this paper is approached by persons who have found themselves answering a charge in the police court or a debt summons, with the request that he will keep their case out of the paper. The request is usually accompanied by the statement that "'the other newspapers have promised not to publish if we will not''; which is indirectly flattering to the ''North-China Daily News'' but really has nothing Whatever to do with the affair. It is further urged that the applicant will probably lose his job if his name appears in such a connexion; to which again there is a very obvious retort, though,' for no less obvious reasons, one forbears to make it. And sometimes comes the final argument that, ''I have spoken to Mr. This or Judge That and he is quite willing'' (sometimes even ''would be glad'') to have it kept out."' This device invariably finishes the discussion, as we happen to know that it is untrue. Judges and magistrates in Shanghai never attempt to interfere with publication of proceedings before them, unless they see reason to do so officially and then it would be done at the outset of the hearing.

Now leaving out the cases which a judge might decide to hear in comerd, the unsavoury details of the divorce court and, occasionally, the medical evidence in inquests, where it is merely revolting and from the public point of view immaterial, we may say frankly that the rule of the "North-China Daily News'' is and has for many years been to publish. There are, of course, cases of no public interest, although those in which we are asked not to publish very rarely come among them: and again it may happen that a case is missed, the reporters not knowing that it was coming on and being too busy, for various reasons, to call at all the courts. But that is a rare event and certainly does not affect the rule. British justice is open to all the world and even courts publicity. One can imagine cases in which judges themselves would be relieved if it were not so, but how very seldom do they shut their doors! Furthermore, in a place like Shanghai, there are special reasons for publication. A foreigner may, for example, be charged with knock-

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account