The Archive · 1932

THE ULTIMATUM

Feb, 20.

Whether the Chinese authorities will be able to comply with the Japanese ultimatum, in respect of either the withdrawal of the 19th Route Army from Chapei or the other conditions imposed, will be known to many before. these lines are read. The wisdom of compliance can hardly be urged without running the danger of appearing to ignore the depth of feeling which the terms have aroused in the minds of the Chinese, Yet if a decision were taken to comply, few detached observers, could cavil at! it. "It would help to prove that the travail of the last three weeks, productive as it has been of heroic resistance by Chinese troops, had created a Giseipline and 1 corporate spirit, the absence of which had constituted one of the main grounds of criticism of China's mental equipment. This opinion frankly expressed in the belief that, while the special interests of Shanghat—from which China's own general interests cannot be 'Beparated—would thus be best served, the acceptance of General 'Uyeda's terms would put China in a strong position. At the same time it is recognised that there—may' considerable difficulty in schooling an awakened national fervour to so calmly a calculating suppression of its natural instinct. Yet, when the re considered in the light of previous Japanese assertions, it must be admitted that they tacitly acknowledge the force of many of contentions, They leave open the way to negotiation, if indeed that is Japan's desire. Any loss of dignity incurred in their acceptance would be fully counter balanced by the enormous strengthening of China's position in the eyes of the world, No sympathetic friend of Chi would wish to say one word in disparagement of a rejection of this view, Equally would this journal deplore expression of any Sentiment which encouraged exposure of Chinese soldiers to an unequal contest with the well-equipped army of Japan, It refuses to endorse the argument that China has nothing to lose iby resistance, It would rather contend that gains already made could be consolidated by a disciplined and dignified military withdrawal in accordance with the Japanese terms, This considered opinion docs not conflict with the attitude taken by the "North-China Daily News" in unequivocal disapproval Japan's recourse to the armed argument in' Shanghai. From the outset, in these columns, there has been a denial of the justification which Japanese apologists have sought sedulously to establish. The decision to apply that argument to the heart, as it were, of one of the largest cities of the world has shown a deplorable disregard of international well-being the reaction of which on Japan's political reputation is being now only dimly perceived. The manner of the application, in its revelation of the complete lack of a sense of proportion and of an ability to inculcate discipline into Japanese civilians, and sailors, has. brought about a painful revision of views. A Year ayo adi were pointing proudly to the sureness of Japan's power of wisely guiding the con-duet of her nationals here. Now apologists, have to fall back ignominiously, in defence Japanese "irregularities," on the very defects with which Chinese actions have been saddled, Much nas to be attributed to ill leunsidered propagandist effort over which the Japanese authorities exercised insufficient control. Tt was responsible, the main, for the very exaggerate led view taken by. Japanese residents here of the actual: extent of the danger to which they were exposed by the so-called Janti-Japanese activities. That view was communicated to Japan land thus appeared to warrant in ~|the eyes of the panese public what was in reality a most imprudent flourish of naval force. Tt has thrown upon the Japanese military authorities the heavy burden of restoring a much Hdamaged prestige.

A message from Tokyo has suggested that Japanese opinion regards the weighty appeal of the Council of the League as prejudiced document. That such fa view can be taken of that appeal, shows the extent to which blindness can go. The Council took "due note of Japan's jevievances. It would have failed egregiously in judicial perception if it had not made it clear that the major issue now the delinquencies of China, but the possible intentions of Japan, in defiance of the assurances Iwhich she has so often given and solemnly sealed. Anyone who describes the note as lacking in impartiality is devoid of apprecia-_ tion of the meaning of words land the decencies of diplomatic usage. Japan has, indeed, to ask herself who are her real friends. Those who have consistently recognised the justice of her complaints but refused to applaud her recent departure from prescribed means of enforcing them fare far worthier of the title than unthinking champions whose chief inspiration appears to be an inveterate disbelief in the existence of any Chinese or in the intelligence of statesmen in Europe or Americé [Such champions are poor mentors for Japan. 'They can maintain their precarious position only by pretending -that the dangers, with which the Settlement is now confronted, are not directly due to Japanese actions. 'The influx of 600,000 refugees, the undermining of the Settlement' administration, the breach the Settlment's integrity and all that those developments imply, may have their remote Jeauses in the defects of Chinese polity. They carnot, except by the -wilfully blind, be logically attributed to anything—but Japan's application of the Manchurian technique to the Yangtze Valley. They have resulted in the creation of 2 position to which the admitted follies of the Chinese Government and the Chinese people are practically irrelevant. If this is not plain, from the trend of the Councils measured appeal and from the Jeomments on that appeal in the world's press, then the friends, as distinct from the incorrigible, apologists, of Japan have reason to be sorely distressed. This has a'lesson both for China and Japan. To China it should provide an additional argument for avoiding the futility of rejection of the Japanese ultimatum. To Japan it should come as a stimulus to frank and fearless' reconsideration of her policy and actions, leading, it is to be hoped, to a speedy recovery of her much b: valued and highly' statesman! cooperation with international endeavour in this great count:

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account