The Archive · 1928

Security for a Loan

Defendants state that they are holding the title deeds of Lot No.

701 in the Hongkong & Shanghai Bank as security for a loan of 5,000, and of this amount Tls. 4,412) is due to defendants by their late compradore, Ku Lam-hoi, and that they are quite willing to hand over the title deeds provided his widow will pay them the sum of Tls. 4,412.

Mr. Wing said that the action was brought by a Portuguese woman of Chinese race who was illiterate, and it was easy to understand that she was probably unaware of what had happened as between hor husband and the firm for which he had acted as compradore.—It was only recently that she had! obtained the right to administer the te, having had to go to Macao to prove her case in the Court there, That Court had established her} position as the widow of Ku Lam-hoi, and, according to Portuguese! law, plaintiff? claimed the right of administratrix of her husband's! estate. Ku Lam-hoi had died in 1924 und no claim was made to the widow for any liabilities owing by Counsel on behalf of plaintitt wrote a letter on April 21, 1927, to the defendant company, requesting the delivery of the title deeds to Lot No. 9701, but no answer of any' ature was received to his communication, Plaintiff could take no) further action at that time in the atter, having no legal status, and ne months passed, Finally letters of administration were obtained by plaintiff on December &, 1927. The case was quite simple: Chinese law, had nothing whatever to do with the case. His client as a Portuguese citizen, and as the lawful administratrix of the estate, desired the return of the title deeds.

The Plaintiff's Evidence Gee Wah-sze, who was called, suid that-she was the widow of Ku Lam-hoi, and that she was registered at the Portuguese Consulate-General at Shanghai, She could not read nor write, and was married when she was 18 years of age. Witness had to go to Bia to obtain the estate papers from the Portuguese Court, establishing her claim as being the! widow of Ku Lam-hi By Mr. Newman:—She was reg-intered at the Portuguese Consulate-General, Shanghai, on December 19, 1927, and had not registered in previous' years. At the- time of her husband's death they were living apart. After her husband's death she Went to the Consulate to make inquiries and was shown a book in which her husband had registered another woman, his concubine, as is wife. Witness had taken action in the Provisional Court against three defendants because they had refused her admittance into her husband's family.

Mr. Newman contended that his clients were fully justified in their actions. There were two rival parties claiming the documents, and Messrs, Shewan, Tomes & Ca. were, and had been, willing to hand over the title deeds upon the settlement of their claim. Both parties had called upon his clients to hand over, the documents, and, in that unhap jon, they had written to suggesting methods be adjusted. To that letter his clients received no reply. Cuunsel sail that present suit was one which was trying to make the British Court a form for the set: lement of a

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account