The Archive · 1928

Position of the Defendants

Mr. Wing said that his client's position was perfectly clear. The plaintiff was subject to the jurisdic~ tion of the Portuguese Court, and would therefore be compelled to administer the estate according to Portuguese law. He would point out that the debt owing to the Hongkong & Shanghai Bank was incurred by the compradore's son, and had nothing to do with the estate. If the concubine or son desired to bring action in the matter, they could do so through the Portuguese Court. As far as the will in favour of the concubine and son was concerned, counsel contended that it was a fabrication fat the last moment. According to Mr, Da Silva's evidence, the only valid will recognized was that which was made in accordance with Portuguese law.

Mr. Newman said that, in connection with the charge of intermeddling, which was really the question of import as far as his clients were concerned, his Lordship would notice, from the correspondence which had passed between Mr. Wing. and himself, that they had done everything possible in the matter. If there was any third party, tainly was not his clients, but the compradore's son. Throe years after the death of Ku Lam-hoi, like bolt from the blue his clients received a letter from Mfr, Wing on Dehalf of Gee Wah-ste asking for particulars of certain property held by them on behalf of Ku Lam-hoi, whom ake claimed as her husband?, But Mesira. Shewan, Tomes & Ca.

new only Gui Cheng-sze as his ie, and the issue of that marriage his son, and they did right in lznoring the letter from Mr. Wing. Letters of administration taken out by plainti Provisional Court, but his clients, had received notice of the will made by the compradore in favour of son. Under the circumstances, they could not hand over the title dees to either one or the other.

In fact, the concubine and son were unwilling to give fresh xecurity. With reference to the question of nationality, Mr. Newman said that the Consular Body had decided that, unless persons could produce tion papers in chan citizenship, there would be no recognition, otherwise there would only he chaos. He contended that hia clients had not intermeddled with the affairs of the estate, bat that they had carried out' the dying wishes of the compradors and that, since no advice had been received from plaintiff until three years after the death of Ku Lam hoi, there was no case to a At this stage, his Lordshi made the suggestion as to being issued by the Court for the disposal of the land, and adjourned tthe hearing till this morning to ive oth parties the opportunity to arrive at an understanding.

On Thursday no agreement had been reached, and Mr. Wing asked that an order be made to return the title deeds with. out the consent of the son of the concubine. Judge Sir Peter Grain pointed out that if this were done, the defendants could refuse to Viquidate the debt to the bank, which was really the compradore's debt. The bank then would refuse to give the documents, and endless litigation would then involve, Mr. Newman asked for an adjournment in order to discuss the matter further with the compradore, the only party not agreeing, and who asked until Monday to think it over. This was granted,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account