The Archive · 1922

PLAINTIFF Not a Paragon

Mr. Wing summed up briefly for plaintiff. He said he had never suggested that his client was a paragon and a model of all that a wine merchant's assistant should be, but he did claim that in a position of great difficulty and responsibility plaintiff did about as well as could be expected. So far as was in his power, he did his best to comply with defendant's instructions to send $1,000 monthly, but at this end there was a perpetual struggle in order to satisfy creditors. Counsel did not attempt to justify the overdraft for Tls. 3,000 except in so fanas to say that plaintiff was actuated by the knowledge that the sale of the house in Cainada would cover that transaction. That sale put a different aspect on the matter. The other so-called overdrafts were not overdrafts at all, but were items in the nature of a counter-claim against plaintiff in connexion with the unsuccessful shipment to Vancouver. As to this, it might not have been strictly in accordance with the letter of defendant's instructions, but plaintiff acted to the best of his ability and, as he considered, in the best interests of the firm. His action was within the general scope of his employment, and_ if there had been an error of judgement he, as an employee, could; not be held responsible for losses! incurred. Counsel added that he did not press for Mrs. Pomeroy's expenses on this journey, though if the expenses were paid it would not be without precedent. The; trip was a bona fide journey undertaken in the execution of his duty as plaintiff conceived it.

His Jordship reserved judgement.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account