The Archive · 1927

The Hope of Better Things

Aug. 20.

The exodus from Nanking must be accepted as a fairly certain sign that the several "Nationalist" armies are defeated past all power of rally-jing. Assuming that this is true, it spells the disintegration of movement that has certainly Jdone China no good; but we should be much more cheerful about it if the collapse of "Nationalism" in the field involve oda definite promise of some-[thing better to follow. This monotonous sweeping to' and fro lof huge armies, which advance Jat enormous cost and register' doubtful victories, only to break. jup because they cannot stand. [success and retreat again at even cost to the country, achieves nothing, decides nothing and holds out no promise. A war that would end war in China would be cheap if it cost sum equivalent to the present national debt and involved the: loss of a million lives. We could then say: "Horrible! But thank Heaven it's over."

With all the ruinous taxation, the interruptions trade and normal—_econ-amic life, the unspeakable miseries inflicted upon the Chinese people, nothing ever seems to happen that is final and decisive. We are not even sure now, after the enormous damage. Jdone by the Reds in this country and the spectacular reaction Jagainst Soviet control by the several Kuomintang commanders, that we are actually rid of the Red blight. Even while denouneing Communism in bitter invective, Nanking has continued to lapply so many of the lessons taught China by the Bolshevist missionaries, particularly in relations with the foreigner, that it!

difficult to discover the advantages to be derived by the Kuomintang's widely advertised change of heart. Violent anti. foreign demonstrations by the wretched labour folk have been suppressed, not out of any consideration for the foreigner but because the Red Russians actual-controlled the mob and because their influence could only be: checked through suppression of ithe mob. Also there have been. outrages upon the persons of foreigners of late. In short the spectacular practices which would, if continued, stir public opinion abroad to endorse military action, have been abandoned in favour of less con-

/spicuous encroachment upon foreign rights. Slow suffocation has been substituted for the extermination of foreign interests, more murderous looking Here there has been a change in practice but no real [change of heart. "Nationalism" still proposes to reduce the forner to such a position that there will be no conspicuous con-

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account