The Archive · 1922

The Press at Council Meetings

For the third time a proposal is to be moved that the press shall be admitted to Council meetings. It must be admitted that Mr.

Cecil Holliday argued powerfully for this innovation in a Jetter to the Press. He says, what 1s quite true, that nobody in electing a Councillor knows what his views are on any particular subject, but votes for him on grounds of general suitability; that ratepayers do not know what is happening or even, very often, what has happened, until long after the event; and that the upshot is public apathy in municipal affairs, ill-instructed asserting, what is palpably ab- {criticism and a lack of criticism ofidered impracticable. We hope the healthy and helpful kind and a want of touch and sympathy between the body of ratepayers and the Council. There is nothing in what Mr. Holliday says suggestive of want of confidence in the Council; on the contrary, he wishes to help them as much as the ratepayers.

Yet we are not convinced that the admission of the -press at Council meetings is practicable. Setting aside the mechanical difficulties of the scheme, by which we mean that it would be literally impossible for some newspapers and seriously inconvenient for, the others to report Council meetings, without going to the expense of an additional reporter—it is a plain fact that no other Council in the world stands in the same position us does that of Shanghai. It resembles a Cabinet much more than it does the municipal bodies of Europe or America. Even in apparently normal municipal matters, like land purchase, telephone or tram extensions and water supply, political considerations are involved, when {premature publicity might ruin the whole negotiations. Against all this, we certainly "think would be advantageous that the public should be given more and more punctual news of what is done by the Council, which they are actually coming to regard as a sort of Vehmgericht, The Municipal Gazette might well be amplified and should contain the fullest possible summary of Council and sub-committee meetings, of which all we hear nowadays is that, like the sailor and his lass in the old song, They met, they kissed, they part-As many have done before.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account