The Archive · 1922

German Reparations in Kind

Adverse Effect on British Industry The "Bulletin" of the British Engineers' Association publishes the text of a letter addressed by Mr. D, A. Bremner, Director of the Association, to the Prime Minister on the suggestion that part payment in kind of German reparations might take the form of the supply by Germany of the machinery, etc., for a number of large electric generaling stations and for the electrification of British railways. The letter enters a strong and consider: ed protest against such a course, and expresses the hope that a decision in so grave a matter to the organizations interested will not be taken without consultation with representatives of the engineering industry.

It is pointed out that the engineering trades are amongst the most highly technical and skilled industries, and that whereas the economic importance of the "quality" of industry has hitherto received little recognition in this country, Germany's trade policy has shown a keen appreciation of the superior economic value of industries producing a high value per man-hour. As "engineering is the basic industry supporting the entire material structure of mechanical civilization." the preservation of our own engineering industry is declared to be a vital necessity. 1t is, moreover, rapidly progressive, and for this of all countries to fall behind in the race "would be disastrous.""

The letter continues:

"To allow even one important section of it, as for example, heavy electrical engineering, to be starved of the most advanced and costly class of work and consequently to decline into a state of inanition would be to tempt Fate. In neither peace nor war could we succeed without it, and by no means whatever could it be suddenly roused again into efficient action when the supreme necessity arose.

"The construction of our own electric power stations and the electrification of our own railways would have an incalculable effect on the vigour and efficiency of the engineering trades in general, and the electrical engineering trade in particular, thereby substantially increasing our chance of securing the export trade, without which we! could not survive. On the other hand, the prodigal gift of that war to Germany would similarly advantage her and enhance her engineering prestige at the expense of our own. Moreover, it would strengthen Germany's position in our home market.

Incidentally, it may be pointed out that it is incorrect to say that the machinery and plant supplied by Germany would cost us nothing. They would cost us the corresponding proportion of the gold mark. indemnity due to this country under the treaty and included in our na-} tional balance-sheet."

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account