duly 9.
There really can be little \difference of opinion between ithe Shanghaj Telephone Company and the public. Complaints against a telephone service, even installed by the Archangel Gabriel and automatically operat-jed in Elysium, there always will be. Perhaps on the working of jhe Shanghai system a newspaper has a special right to speak. Journalists probably use the telephone more than most people.
the basis of that experience—\joined with personal knowledge fof automatic systems in other] countries—it may be asserted iconfidentiy that Shanghai is very' fortunate indeed. Although the. public is readier to throw bricks than bouquets, Shanghai also appreciates the efficiency with which the Company converted, the manual into the automatic:
system, ahead of time and in spite of the sudden intrusion, the final stages, of a diversion on the homeric scale. The Company has been frank in its idealings; it has kept the public Jaware of the progress of the installation and done everything possible to educate subscribers in the use of the dial for their own and other subscribers' benefit. In spite of not too creditable efforts of interested parties to disparage its system has proved that it can give Shanghai an efficient service.
Now there comes this controversy over the application of the Anson rates. The Company is abundantly right in its contention that those rates became chargeable as soon as the conversion had been effected. The Councils have certified that the Franchise terms have been met jand the Company has proceeded to levy the charges with retroactive effect from March 27. Notice that this would be done was. clearly shown in the Franchise published nineteen months ago. The Company, thus logically and legally on unassailable ground, considers that objection to this retroactive charge is unreason-lable. It might go even further ud add that the Franchise being, in effect, a contract pleted between' the Councils behalf of the Ratepayers, und ithe Company, clearly demands, from the telephone subscriber fidelity to the bargain, just as the Company, on its side, has kept its undertakings. So it would seem that anyone who Jdemurs to retroactive payment is in danger of being charged with avoidance of his obligations, In a perfect world this might' lbe upheld to the' limit. The matter is not quite so simple in the minds of the public. They feel that the Company would) have been better advised if, when announcing the completed conversion, it had called pointed! attention to the implication of ithe event in regard to the Anson Rates. Public memory does not! burden itself with the details Municipal contracts. Refresh-iment of that memory might have gore far to avert the present misunderstanding, for the ae tual operation of securing. the formal sanction of the two Coun-ils to the application of the [Anson Rates was bound to take! time. This journal believes that Shanghai's Public Utility Companies are run with admirable regard for decent. principles: lof service. They have seduliously to avoid any—appear-lance of taking undue advantage! lof their monopolies to enforce procedure impossible for private concern. It is the Coun-ils' duty to impress this upon them. The Telephone is working at soon have to take attract more capital if development of the expanding telephone service is to be secured.
desire to insist on its legal rights in the circumstances eminently practical and in keeping with its duty to the shareholders. The question seems to boil itself down to this: is the Company wise to risk ths loss of feoodwill entailed in a belief, misguided though it be, that the telephone subscriber should not! be saddled with this retroactive payment? Could it not, after Jeonsultation with the Council at some compromise in which the pecuniary sacrifice involved would be outweighed by: the public's recognition of its generosity? Nothing can be worse for the Councils and the Public Utility "Companies between them to give the impres ion that they do not fully take jieto account the feelings of the "small_man" who, oversensitive he may be just now, is apt to picture himself as the eternal the upper and the
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.