The Archive · 1928

Borodin and China

To, the Editor of the Nowrn-Citia DaiLy News."

Sin—There is certain interest created by the publication of a letter written by Anna Louis Strong in the December issue of "Asia" (1927), explaining that Borodin was an in nonce to moderation in the Nation-list Movement. I happened to be around when Strong, Borodin, and Kung were engaged in conversation, and wish to make a correction of the impression given by the remarks 2 HI Ht, Kung, which were of an Inquisitive nature, and not a positive statement as mentioned in the letter.

Dr. Kung raised the question of why Borodin would oppose his advocacy of dividing the industrial profits between capital ard labour, but allow' extreme radicalism to reign over the territories under the Hankow Government at that time. Borodin seemed to be a conservative, not even moderate, at one instance when hho did not favour the division of industrial. profits between capital and labour, while on the other hand, he proved to be an exponent of the "Red" programme. The other remarks regarding Sun Fo and Hsu Chien's radical speeches were made by Borodin und not by" Kung quoted in the letter. In the exact words of Borodin, (if T am not mistaken) he said, "I pulled the coat of Hsu Chien and entreated him of to make promises to the labourfers and peasants, which could not be fulfited," when he was making wild promises of the Utopian type.

Tt seems that Borodin China as an agent of the programme, but he did not expect Uncontrollable conflagration after hho had started the fie. He attempt check the activities of the extremists, but before he succeeded, the reactionary movement swept and forced with to leave behind him the scone of rain. I believe. that Borodin's moderacy was a timely tone, and that he was simply awaiting' an opportune time to effect Red Revolution in China, Tam, ete, J. We Shanghai, Jan, 21, 1028,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account