The Archive · 1928

Senator Bingham Again

To, the Editor of the Nowrit-CuiNa Dairy News, Sin—You have been so kind to give much space to certain remarks I waa reported t0 have made Honolulu. Although there we no reporters present at the dinner, which was a private affair, and alth: tough the story, which was printed {in an irresponsible paper in Honolulu! two weeks after the event, contained many serious errors of' fact and quoted me as saying a number of things which T did not say, including the ancient story about the signs in the parks in Shanghai, you. very naturally assumed that the report swas correct. And on the basis of! that assumption chose to accuse me: of deliberate falsehood.

T did say at thee dinnes, and hay repeated it a number of times since then, that about 60 per cent. of the taxes inthe International "Sette. ments are paid by Chinese and that these Chinese taxpayers are not allowed to use the parks of which they bear more than one-half of the expense. Is this true or is it false?

T had heard the story about the sign many times and was told in Shanghai that story was not true. Naturally ¥ never repeated it. was also told in Shanghai that the Ghinese were not allowed to use the parks. I judge from the interest you have shown in the question of my veracity that this Hory isnot true. If you will write me that the Chinese are permitted to use. the parks and are permitted to be invitfdas guests to luncheon or dinner at the Shanghai Club, [shall be lad to give it the widest possible Tublicity, for T desire to clu no me Justice to anyone.

Tam, ete, United States Senate, Washington, Dee. 20, 1927.

It is'ony necessary to remind Senator Bingham that the "Literary Digest" also took the trouble to reprint his "statements from this "irresponsible Honolulu paper," and: our readers will remember that in -orponse to a telegram from a well-known American resident here, leading American in Honolula wired to the effect that the Senator had been correctly reported. However, in view of Senator Bingham's letter and his denial, we do not propose to. Pursue the matter further with the exception of one comment. That is ith reference to the threadbare subject of clubs and parks in Shanghai. "In a leading article we showed at the time the Senator's remarks appeared, how ill at ease would Chi nese be in a foreign club and vice versa, making due allowance for national habits, but it may also be added for his information that many times during the past few years Chinese have attended luncheons and dinners in the Shanghai Club. As for the parks the position should be obvious even to a casual visitor.

When laid out they were made large enough only for the accommodation of the then small foreign population, and to-day they are cramped enough even for such a purpose. Were they thrown open to the whole populace to-day, it is obvious that the result would be to deny foreign children the few places they have for open-air exercise which ie so necessary in this climate and which it is difficult to obtain for them owing to the environment of the Settlement,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account