The Archive · 1928

The Tale and the Truth

falsification of accounts. Except that the method of covering up the deficiency was described by ithe prosecuting counsel as "the most ingenious system with which the Audit Department had ever had to deal," the fraud is commonplace enough. It is the circumstances surrounding it which cannot but awake astonishment and, most people we think, sympathy with the convicted' man.

The prosecution showed that the guilty man had been an income-tax collector for many years. In the year 1919 he was paid £700 a year, (at one time apparently he was getting a if little more), but by 1926 this was cut down to £950 owing to the reduction of his work due to the transference of London County Council officials from his area. Something amiss was detected in the man's accounts last January, he was questioned, and admitted that he had been appropriating money for "si years—the total appear: amount to £2,465—but he that he had got into the hands of money-lenders, owing to the reduction of his' salary. Here we may quote in full from the "Times" report:

Accused told the Magistrate that he purposely entered a payment of £11,000 on a wrong date so that the matter could be-covered, and he made a fall confession on his own I could have utilized that money," he said, "to cover up the deficiency and the matter could have gone on' indefinitely, but Twas tired of the worry that was hanging over me. I was living a life of hell because of the worry of the situation. For 25 years T have been connected with this OTe, I had to collect about £1,100,000 a year, and for that T received a remuneration of £750 a year. Out of that I had to provide an office, and pay th: staff and incidental expenses. The work was so enormous thi was impossible for me to deal with it in the time. I got behindhand and \my remuneration was in consequence stopped for three months. I had mo means and had to resort to moneylenders to get money to pay the clerks and office expenses. The result was that from that day T got into difficulties. I used Revenue money, fully intending to pay back, but it got too much for me, and I made up my mind to dis-lose the whole thing."

Mr. Mustoe said it was true that £100 of accused's remunera-tien was stopped, not for three months, but for six weeks, in consequence of the non-performance of duty. The money, however, was afterwards paid to him.

Income-tax collectors are. traditionally nobody's friend, although it is just possible that if they were approached with less suspicion, the taxpayer might actually gain in the long run. But if they were ten times the bloodsuckers they are depicted, one could not withhold one's feeling that this man's case is a hard one. In such a district as Charing Cross he certainly would not get an office big enough for his requirements under £100 a year if so little, with rates, water, heating and light to he added. If he only had two clerks, and he clearly had more than one, their salaries would run to at least another £300. So that for himself there remains at the outside £850 a year if so much, subject to the vicious system of having all pay suspended for weeks or months if his work gets into arrears: and with all this he is entrusted with the handling of over a million sterling annually. When, through the accident of the work becoming less, the man's salary is cut to £350, he may have got on without clerks, but an office he must have, the charge for which, of course, would bear more heavily on his new scale of pay than the, perhaps, higher rental had borne on him before. With costs of living what they are now in England, what right has the Board of Inland Revenue to expect that its subordinates handling large sums of money, under a system so complicated as to make fraud by no means difficult, shall steer clear of moneylenders and remain honest?

The wonder is not that defalcations occur sometimes but that. they occur so seldom. Bureaucracy is a term express sive of contempt, and on some grounds deservedly. But it also implies no small burden of responsibilities shouldered for very inadequate pay. The attraction of all civil service is that it is "safe": unless'a man falls out with his immediate superiors, he need not fear dismissal; and he can usually, though not always, look forward to a pension. But the terms of the pension itself, when closely examined, often make it less valuable than it at first appears; and, on the holder's death, the reversion, if any, to the widow is extremely meagre. Meanwhile the higher a man rises in his service, the more is expected of him in all sorts of ways outside his office duties and the greater his risk of running into debt. In the, recent case of gambling in franes by Foreign Office clerks, the Committee of Inquiry commented on the inadequacy of their pay as a direct incentive to practices unbefitting—their position, The case of members of the foreign Consular Service is particularly hard, They are expected to live in the same style as men who make ten times their pay, and, what is more, they cannot properly discharge the duties of their station if they do not. The tendency of the House of Commons towards cheese-paring in some directions and utter wastefulness in others has often been stigmatized. Nowhere is it more vividly shown than in the field of foreign service. At Home there has long been loud complaint of the swollen condition of the permanent Departments. The remedy of employing fewer officials and paying them higher salaries would probably work wonders both in economy and efficiency. Meanwhile it is to the standing credit of the Civil Service all round that cases like that of the unhappy income-tax collector of St. Martin's West are so few and far between,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account