The Archive · 1928

A FOREIGN LADY'S MURDER

In the Provisional Court of Ap" peals, on Wednesday afternoon, Judges Zinr (presiding), Chin and Chan, with whom sat Mr. C. Whitamore, British Consular Deuty, heard the appeal of the Police against a decision of 16 years imprisonment, imposed by Judge Li Ching-foo, on a hawker, who was charged in connection with the robbery and murder of the Into Mrs. E, T. Forestier on) November 2 last, Mr. E. T. Maitland, Prosecuting Solicitor, appeared for appellenta: and Mr. "Tsu Fo-sz was present fox, respondent. the course of a most contra dietary statement, Nyoeh Kyung-ssu, the house coolie, who admitted have ing committed the murder and who had been sentenced to death by the Court of First Instance, stated that the confession which he had made to the police was trae, excepting the part in which he had implicated espontlent. Respondent did not enter the kitchen, where the murder took place. The door was open bub he did not enter. Another man named Tsu Wei-ling assisted him, Tsu stabbing deceased and he (pri= soner) striking her: twice with an axe. After he had struck the blows, Prisoner dropped the axe on the Gromaxamined by Me, Mallands the respondent at his request ho wanted him to return {$100 which prisoner owed him. He new what business prisoner had if going to the house and he knew de ceased did not owe him (prisoner), $400, as he had previously alleged, Prisoner gave him $90 of the stolen money and added another $10 later. He implicated respondent because the latter had once threatened him {in a teashop. Respondent. did not have any bloodstains on him. His statement in connection with spondent was absolutely untrue Went to Get Money In answer to the Judges, prisoner said that respondent went with him {in order to get the money. He saw Tea stabbing deceased. Deceased at first attacked prisoner and Tsu came to his assistance and fought with her. Tsu did not take part in the fight at the beginning but later he managed to get a knife to stab her.

'A houseboy in deceased's employ stated that he went out at 1.80 p.m and did not know of the murder. He could not see how the prisoner could have known there were servants in the house and that was there alone.

Det.-Supt. Peck then gave evidences of his inquiries and stated that he found a knife on the floor of thd kitchen, as well as a hatchet. There was also a pocket knife on the floor but he could not trace the owner.

Season te reszendent than med up and said that he was Denting voluntarily for respondent, having been appointed by the Court. iis client had no intent to commit 'a murder, he submitted, and did not take with him any weapon when ho went to the place. According to all the evidence, deceased took the kn! from the drawer and the first, prlsoner took it away from her. There was no premeditated murder. It was after the murder that the coolie went upstairs and took the mon That, he stated, could not, be described as robbery: it was larceny. Counsel thought that 16 years was 'a severe sentence but he would ask the Court to confirm it, if it did not reduce it.

Mr. Maitland stated that there was no doubt about the matter. The evidence was all against respondent. His presence was moral support for the others. A serious crime had been committed and the only punish ment was, death, which he would ask the Court to impose.

Todgment was reserved.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account