A feature in the heaving on Fel of the case of China Engineer Ltd, 0, Mr. C, B. Prentice in H.. Supreme Court was a verbal tilt between Mr. H. A, Reeks, for the plaintiffs, and Mi. K. E. Newman for the defence, the latter proposing, the former opposing, a request. tha the action be postponed until the matter be submitted to a lament, said that he serve. his decision because he that this question of ar-di tration was far more important than either counsel had realised before coming to court, In regard to the matter, Judge Grane Jones said that counsel for} the plaintiff? should have given the plaintiffs at least two days, notice that he was going to ask for the Rrececdings 1 Te stopped, Mr.
lawman, in reply, said that the defendant had not decided on the'matter until the day before the case game up, but that, having regard to the law'on the subject, he was asking for the stoppage before proceedings opened. There was nothing, he said, in the local laws in the subject as to how the appli-gourt, and he was therefore carry-cation was, to be put afore the 'Mit. A. G, Mossop, the Crown Advocate, said that the mintter was indeed one. for' discretion. The matter was due to an accident. Yet inadvertence had been held to mean ignorance of the law. He sub: mitted that the fatter was Companys "His "Lordship sould rose negligence on the part 0 notice that the allotments: had: been made in March 2 last. Mr. P. 8 Tipple, the secretary, had since ex-Diaiiet in an affidavit' that. the oversight was due to a miisunder-Standing between him and. the original secretary, whose name Was not even mentioned.
would draw his Lovdship's attention to the fact that this sane company had been in court before for an almost similar default. The tivo secretaries concerned fi that Matter were Mr, D. ff. Pranets and Messrs. George MeBain, the latter leaving the firm when the former took over the reins of office, Messrs. MeBain left it to Mr, Francis to fle the allotments. and Mr. Francts pleaded" that" he" thought. that Messrs, McBain had. already done 80, The Crown Advocate did not suggest that the General Forge Products had wilfully disobeyed Section 90, but he did think that, they were most unfortunate in their choice of empl ces, each of whom home, ing out the procedure as adopted at ott it to the other to do the work Mr. Recks, quoting authorities, Francis was doing the filing and Elt8 Messrs, MeBain thought said that an agreement to refer vice versa, and now they had Mr. ways be pleaded, matters te arbitration cannot, especially where al-tipple doing the same thing with the parties refute the contract. 'The some anon, defendants had cancelled the' contract, Mr. Reeks said, producing Tt was gross negligence on the company's part in not seeing that substantiation of this' a letter fror did. "their: work' the defendant's lawyer to that effect. properly, he continued, For 16; The amount years now he, in his position as volved in the action Grovn Advocate, had been doing his the amount the best to impress upon companies the need for consulting their lawyers matters of this kind. We Was not posing the application "for an pretension of time, a3 the allotment Mr, Rooks submitted, and he would athing to go to arbitration about, of the shares had to be could. not be so done wi therefore ask that the defendants coUld, not, be so done withen enter thie pleadings, Mr.
Newman, in reply, said that] Dosing the the times periods But he was op: petition for relist froom hho was still-entitied to ask for the Penne, tee Retition for relief, from Proceedings to be stopped. The the whole matter Was. gross fendant agreed to pay to the! negligence on the part of the com-plaintiffs the amount of money me volved in sections 1 and 2, but section 3 would not be submited to] was, therefore, "asking. his arbitration, In, reply to a state. lordship to make an oder granting ment made by Mr. Reoks that. fan extension of time, but that no the defendant} mention Wwas to be mad agreement to the relief from the penalty. could not be brought up, MIN.
'Judge Grant Jones here said that man retorted that in' that case he was not disposed to grant the neither could the plaintiffs ask for application as in nis opinion the the money for the work and labour. ahidavit not sulicient. to. sup-ort the petition. To enforce the mnalty proceedings would of course A Company's Slackness aye to be taken, The Crown Advoeat A, motion by the General Forg trar of Compani nets, Ltd, for an extension accept the return of allot-time in which to file a return of the ments of shares after th allotment of shares over the six time of six weeks. For weeks period was granted by Judge necessary for the Court to grant an Grant Jones in HM. Supreme jon of the time period, and Court on Feb. 6, The application as the allo for relief from "penalty, however, asked tment had to be fied, ip to grant it. Mr. Brown said that in view of represented by Inv. M. B, Brown, o was not ranted, "Petiioners were what his lordship had said he could Platt, White-Cooper" &' Ca., the only say that the company Grown Advocate appearing for the guaranteed "that nothing of this Registrar of Companivs. ature would happen again, as they 'Mr, Brown, opening the case for would take stern measures to sec the applicants, said that this was that the secretaries carried out motion for' relief in respect of their duties in this respect. The Permission to be granted matter has all due to inadvertence. certain allotments. "An His Lordship giving, judgment, asked that the director is an application under and other officials of the company (3) of the Company be relieved from the penalty. which they wore liable for the default of Section 90 of the Hongkong the penalty to which they are liable Companies Ordinance Act. for default in complying with Tu support of this motion, the Section 90 (1) of the Ordinance in secretary of the company, ad fled failing to forward to the Registrar affidavit, in which he stated of Companies within six weeks that for a time he had acted as thereof respectively the return of assistant secretary in the firm, and certain allotments" and that' the not formally given the position Company be permitted to file the until October, "1932, There had necessary, returns with the egisbeen some misapprehension as to trar forthwith. The affidavit. in Wit duties he was. o carry, out support of the application gives* as land what the secretary had to. the ground for relief that there was Bach "had, therefore, thought. that some misunderstanding between the the other had attended to the Sling present Secretary, who was at the of the allotment of, shares. There time acting as assistant to the then been no intention of acting Secretary, and the latter ax to the wrongly, the whole matter being due exact division of duties. between to inadvertence. them each being under the impres.
All the evidence, continued Mr.
Brown, was in support of this. He tien that the ling lotments of shares did nat know what atituds opposing of the other. This is a typical counsel was going to take, but he instance ofthe slackness and thought that, reasonable ground inefficiency. with "which affairs are had been disclosed for his Lordship generally conducted in this country to. exercise his discretion "in the ud business is often carried on in matter, as provided.in the Act. The inghai, and the affidavit is ubtercompany was linble to a fine not adequate for the purpose execoding $500 for every day that intended to serve. A mis-the default had continued, and in view of the fact that the non-filing understanding betwen two servants company as to their respective gf the allotment was "due to functions affords no sufficient ground Gnadvertenee, he ached fat for an application to the Court for order be made to extend the time cclief against penalties such as is for the filing of the deexments, and sought here, There has been gross company might exempt from the Dalny Road on Feb. 2.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.