The Archive · 1922

The Egypt Inquiry

To the Editor of the "Norta-Cuina Dairy News."

Sir,—Having read in your paper the result of the Egypt inquiry, it is very surprising to me, that the officers should be blamed for the lack of discipline, of which they were found guilty by the Court of Inquiry.

As anyone knows who follows the sea-faring profession, it is very difficult, and I might say impossible, when a vessel is so heavily listed (as in the case of the Egypt) to have the boats swung out and lowered on the high side of the vessel, and it is quite natural that every one should take to the lower side boats, and I am quite sure that it would be the officers' wish that the passengers, especially women and children, should be safely landed in the ship's boats first.

An Indian crew would not realize that passengers should be lurided first, and as I have had experience with Indian crews during the war, I think T ought to be in a fair position to judge:

During the war, the vessel in which I was serving, was fired upon by an enemy submarine, and though the shots that were fired missed by a good margin. in less than two minutes the lifeboats were filled with the Indian crews' belongings to stich an extent that it would have been impossible at the time to get into any of the boats and it was only by very severe threats at the point of the revolver that the crews belongings were taken out again.

I surmise that most of the officers in the Egypt must have served in the Royal Naval Reserve during the war, and I can hardly think that any breach of discipline could have been omitted, and I can sympathize with them on the results of the inquiry.

I am, ete.,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account